Home
Q&A
Why are members hesitant in providing geographical locations ?

Why are members hesitant in providing geographical locations ?

8
votes

There is no indication what languages are spoken if not Spanish or English.

2989 views
updated Jan 3, 2012
posted by kmaakheru
I always wondered about that! - Silvia, Dec 31, 2011

12 Answers

9
votes

You can and should post a country of origin and fluency level in Spanish and English on your profile. It helps other people to help you.

At first, I was reluctant to fill in this information because of privacy concerns. Once people pointed out the benefits to me, I added the information.

Plus, now that I know where people live, I think it's cool that I have friends all over the world.

updated Jan 3, 2012
posted by JoyceM
My point. - kmaakheru, Dec 30, 2011
6
votes

I too had concerns about privacy. However, if you use a nickname (as most of us do) there isn't much chance that someone is going to do anything with the info we post here IMO. Knowing your city & country doesn't really tell anyone much in regard to security issues. I like to know where someone is located (city/country) when I am communicating with them on here. It makes it a little more interesting! cheese

updated Jan 3, 2012
posted by Gillygaloo
ditto:) - Silvia, Dec 31, 2011
4
votes

I beleive some people are just simply paranoid. LOL LOL

updated Jan 3, 2012
posted by yaction
Es verdad :) - MaryMcc, Dec 30, 2011
Yes, perhaps they are all wanted by the police? - annierats, Dec 31, 2011
be nice! - Silvia, Dec 31, 2011
4
votes

I would like to make a point here and I don't mean to sound insulting but Sinthu, you said this:

when someone answers the question then you will know fi they are spanish or english because of the language they reply in

My first impression is that you are not a native English speaker due to your lack of proper capitalization and punctuation ( we can overlook the fi typo ) but it is apparent that you are by your argument of the matter. I sometimes answer or ask questions in Spanish but I am not a Spanish native or even knowledgable enough to be sure they are correct but if you are at my level in learning I doubt you would see any mistakes so how are you to know? In my case it is easy, look at my profile. We do ask that everyone do this but for some reason many people are afraid to show their origin. Just because this site teaches either Spanish or English tells you absolutely nothing about the native languages of the membership. I know and speak to a number of people from the Mediterranean and the Middle East who can write with perfect English but are still learning both languages so where is your logic? Again, please don't misconstrue this reply as anything other than informative, I mean no disrespect to any of our members.

updated Jan 3, 2012
posted by Yeser007
Oops, sorry I edited Sinthus reply. - MaryMcc, Dec 30, 2011
4
votes

You can not base the language on how the question is asked. I am an English speaker learning to speak Spanish, so I try to ask questions in Spanish.

updated Jan 3, 2012
posted by kdrinning
yes but the language people reply in is the language they speak - sinthu, Dec 30, 2011
Depende, joven. - samdie, Dec 30, 2011
4
votes

When someone answers the question then you will know fi they are Spanish or English because of the language they reply in smile

updated Jan 3, 2012
edited by MaryMcc
posted by sinthu
That's true. I usually base my answer language based on the language of the question. - SonrisaDelSol, Dec 30, 2011
Look at Chefganesh's post and ask where this person is and what language is being spoken. - kmaakheru, Dec 30, 2011
Look at my omment below on kdrinning's post - sinthu, Dec 30, 2011
Hi, don't forget to use capital letters to start a sentence, and for languages :) - MaryMcc, Dec 30, 2011
Not necessarily! - Silvia, Dec 31, 2011
Yes, necessarily, in English anyway not in Spanish. - MaryMcc, Jan 2, 2012
3
votes

I'm tuscantory@aol.com. I was raised in Southern California and had my first Spanish words on the playground in 4th grade. mostly cuss words because the immigrants we played with thouht that was funny. Then of course we learned to count to ten and that was funny to see how fast you could do it.

I traveled to Spain in the summer of 1977, on a scholarship, to Oviedo Asturias, and of course, have since refined my learning processes. I've read Fuenteovejuna and Don Quijote de la Mancha and like Pablo Neruda and Cien Anos de Soledad.

I've been to Tijuana, Mexicali, and Algodones but never much furthur south than Cabo San Lucas, Baja California where my fondest memory is swimming out to a boat to get a fresh bag of camorones given to me by the marineros. I love shrimp.

Does this answer a simple question of where we members might be from?. I am an American born in Texas and educated en espanol through the school system and various social interaction. California sort of says it all. Se habla espanol.

updated Jan 3, 2012
edited by Izanoni1
posted by tuscantory
tuscantory, this is great that you shared your info,but it's much better to put it on your profile page so more people will see it. except may not want to inclued email address. - Gillygaloo, Dec 30, 2011
nice to have teh e-mail, if I ever want to send apicture or something.. - annierats, Dec 31, 2011
2
votes

Yeser007

You would notice that after that post, for clarification I posted as a comment

yes but the language people reply in is the language they speak

I am sorry that I had assumed that the language people replied in was their native language. For example, if someone had asked how to translate a sentence into spanish I would not reply as it is not my native language and I may be wrong. Hence why I would only reply to posts that require proof reading of English writing or as such as as you correctly stated English is my native language. Furthermore, I do not tend to use capital letters for each sentence as firstly I was in a rush when writing that comment and secondly I did not think it was necessary on these types of websites; you may have therefore realsied that I am new to this website.

In conclusion, I am sorry for any misunderstanding caused from my assumption and am not in turn trying to have an argument but am simply stating where the misunderstanding has come from.

updated Jan 3, 2012
posted by sinthu
Now that the dust cleared, let's get back to the question! - Silvia, Dec 31, 2011
No problem Sin, as long as you now understand that the policy of this forum is correct caps and punctuation because of the fact that it is a learning site and not a chatroom. - Yeser007, Dec 31, 2011
:) Yes - sinthu, Jan 3, 2012
2
votes

Sorry folks. I have good reasons to keep my identity under cover.

alt text

updated Jan 3, 2012
posted by Gekkosan
Well, you undercover Venezuelan agents.. - annierats, Jan 1, 2012
2
votes

I really like knowing where people are from! I just love how international this site is, it's, to me one of the pleasures, an answer may come from Hungary or Australia. I think when you first jopin you feel worried, just in case it's not a nice site. Very soon you know it's a brilliant site and wish you had thought up a smarter username for yourself. I'm thinking of changing my donkey for a turtle, progress seems so slow.

updated Jan 3, 2012
posted by annierats
I'm with you Annie, I think it is one of the most intriguing aspects of SD. - Yeser007, Dec 31, 2011
2
votes

I often look at someone’s profile if they have made a grammatical error.

For example if they are a native English speaker and the only error in their post is that they have forgotten a capital letter for a language I may assume it is a typo. I may still edit it because it is one of the errors that irritates me for some reason (mainly because I think it is confusing for people who are learning English) but I will not necessarily feel I need to explain why.

If the poster has not stated their country of origin and/or language levels I will not assume they are a native English speaker as we have many members here who are from different areas of the globe but write English as well, if not better, than many native speakers I know.

updated Jan 3, 2012
posted by MaryMcc
1
vote

Knowing your city & country doesn't really tell anyone much in regard to security issues.

Along with my username, my city and country identify me uniquely.

updated Jan 3, 2012
posted by lorenzo9