Home
Q&A
difference between 'a' and 'para'

difference between 'a' and 'para'

2
votes

Hello All,

I just started to go through the lessons and I bumped into this sentence: 'Juan da el pastel a Jaime'

Can you please explain me why 'a' is used here and not 'por'?

Muchas gracias smile

1010 views
updated Dec 28, 2011
posted by bolondgombita

6 Answers

1
vote

Not that can be used interchangeably, but if someone says:

(Te) Doy un pastel a tí = I am giving you a cake/pastry to you

(Te) Doy un pastel para tí = I am giving you/I give you a cake/patry for you

In Spanish as in English, you understand the first phrase, as the cake might be for you, you actually need more context to determine that, whereas the second phrase is more definite, the cake is for you.

updated Dec 28, 2011
posted by chileno
thanks, this comparison is useful ! - bolondgombita, Dec 28, 2011
1
vote

I understood that it is pretty much interchangable with 'a', as in 'Doy un pastel a tí / Doy un pastel para tí'

Para is wrong there.

Dar already includes "to" a does not mean "to" or "for" there although "a" can mean "to" and "for" in certain circumstances.

Tengo un pastel para ti y te lo daré. Te lo daré a ti esta manzana.

This usage cannot be simply understood by this paragraph, you must study more to grasp it. wink

updated Dec 28, 2011
edited by jeezzle
posted by jeezzle
1
vote

Dar = to give or to give to

A = personal A.

There is nothing to do with para in there.

updated Dec 28, 2011
posted by jeezzle
0
votes

(Te) Doy un pastel para tí = I am giving you/I give you a cake/patry for you

But you are really saying "Te doy un pastel (y este pastel es) para ti"

Te doy a ti algo para ti - but that's really just hammering the point home.

updated Dec 27, 2011
edited by jeezzle
posted by jeezzle
You lost me. Too as in "to" ? If, so, then it is about usage... - chileno, Dec 27, 2011
typo. yes usage. I think I have explained it perfectly. - jeezzle, Dec 27, 2011
hmmm, consider the following: I am giving you a cake, but it isn't for you. - chileno, Dec 27, 2011
0
votes

I'm on it wink Thanks for the examples!

updated Dec 27, 2011
posted by bolondgombita
0
votes

Hello, thanks for your answer.

Though para is not a part of this sentence, I understood that it is pretty much interchangable with 'a', as in 'Doy un pastel a tí / Doy un pastel para tí' and I don't really get the hang of when to use which..

updated Dec 27, 2011
posted by bolondgombita