Home
Q&A
Question about Test

Question about Test

2
votes

Okay so on my tests there are usually questions about what endings to use in sentences, and I know endings to my verbs like -o is for I and I know how to identify them in sentences. But I am just hung up on one thing. My teacher will give us this:

?Jose _______ libro? a. leo b. lees c. lee d. lemos e. leen

And I am hung up on if it means if you are talking to Jose or are you talking to someone else about Jose. Sorry for bad spanish, only in Spanish 1... Thanks

1211 views
updated Dec 12, 2011
posted by JD4SPURS
Welcome to the forum :) - Kiwi-Girl, Dec 12, 2011

5 Answers

1
vote

And I am hung up on if it means if you are talking to Jose or are you talking to someone else about Jose. Sorry for bad spanish, only in Spanish 1... Thanks

and

See but there I don't understand how to tell if the person is talking to Jose or if you are talking to someone about Jose?

That is why we harp so much on correct punctuation here on this forum.

If you are directing the question to José then you must put a comma after his name.

José, ¿lee un libro? or ¿José, lee un libro? Joseph, are you reading a book?

less confusing if you write: José, ¿lees un libro tú? or José, ¿lee un libro usted?

If there is no comma, then it is:

¿José lee un libro? Is José (he) reading a book?

updated Dec 12, 2011
edited by 0074b507
posted by 0074b507
1
vote

The best thing to do probably is to translate it to English:

So you would have

¿Jose _______ un libro?

Does Jose or Is Jose _____ a book?

and your options are

leo / (I) read, am reading

lees / (you/informal (tú)) read, are reading

lee / (she/he/it) reads, is reading

lemos / (we) read, are reading

leen / (they / you (plural)) read, are reading

So which one do you think fits best?

The helpful thing about Spanish question marks is that you can see that you're not speaking to Jose in your example otherwise you'd say: "Jose ¿lees un libro? Jose, are you reading a book? - the question marks only surround the question part.

updated Dec 12, 2011
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by Kiwi-Girl
1
vote

Welcome to the forum.

The subject is Jose and the verb must agree with the subject.

Jose lee un libro. Jose reads a book.

updated Dec 12, 2011
posted by sanlee
0
votes

See but there I don't understand how to tell if the person is talking to Jose or if you are talking to someone about Jose?

updated Dec 11, 2011
posted by JD4SPURS
0
votes

Jose ..lee... un libro but I wonder if the question marks come with the question or it' you way to ask for

updated Dec 11, 2011
posted by xicotillo