Home
Q&A
Which form of should not do you use?

Which form of should not do you use?

2
votes

Is it no debería or no deben I'm trying to say shops should not be fined for putting up christmas decorations but confused on my tenses

781 views
updated Dec 1, 2011
posted by awe4

3 Answers

1
vote

I am not native but I would say "no deberían" for should not and "no deben" for must not.

Let's see what the natives say.

updated Dec 1, 2011
posted by ian-hill
Well, we can be two non-natives that are incorrect. - 0074b507, Dec 1, 2011
1
vote

Half and half je je smile

I would use - no deberían - the conditional but because it's 'the shops' plural you will need the use deberíaN in the third person plural.

As far as I understand it:

deber (present tense) + infinitive is used to express a supposition, something that is probable (must be) or obligation (must do something)

Maria debe de haber llagodo.

Mary must have arrived.

but debería is used to make a suggestion (ought to/should) or suggest moral obligation.

updated Dec 1, 2011
posted by Kiwi-Girl
Shops are the object being fined. The person of shouldn't depends on the subject imposing the fine unless we use the impersonal or passive voice. - 0074b507, Dec 1, 2011
1
vote

no debe= mustn't, not have to

no debería= shouldn't

no debiera in subjunctive mood

updated Dec 1, 2011
posted by 0074b507