Home
Q&A
Why do "ser" and "estar" have a gerundio?

Why do "ser" and "estar" have a gerundio?

4
votes

Hola!

Random question here...could anyone explain why ser and estar have their own gerundio?

When would one ever use them? I cannot think of any examples...

Estoy estando enojada - I am being angry?

Maybe: Estoy estando de acuerdo contigo - I am agreeing with you

4014 views
updated Nov 12, 2011
edited by SonrisaDelSol
posted by SonrisaDelSol
good question! - billygoat, Nov 12, 2011
Thank you, billy :D - SonrisaDelSol, Nov 12, 2011

7 Answers

6
votes

Hi Sonrisa! smile

We use them all the time. These examples are very colloquial:

Siendo así... acepto.

Estás siendo maleducado.

Me siento bien estando contigo

Seguía estando en el mismo lugar

Siendo profesor, no comprendo cómo no confías en la enseñanza.

updated Nov 12, 2011
posted by cogumela
Cogumela to the rescue again! ;)) - territurtle, Nov 12, 2011
Muchas gracias cogu!! - SonrisaDelSol, Nov 12, 2011
5
votes

I am being angry?

Me estoy enojando. (in spanish we use this phrase 90% of the time to mean I am being angry)

Me estoy sintiendo enojado/enojada.

Estoy llegando a enojarme.

I am agreeing with you

Estoy de acuerdo contigo (in spanish, 90% of the times we use this phrase to mean I am agreeing with you)

Estoy llegando a un acuerdo contigo.

Estoy acordando contigo.

Estamos llegando a un acuerdo.

Me estoy poniendo de acuerdo contigo.

Siento que llegamos a un acuerdo.

Verb to be in spanish is a pain in the **** for the anglophone people because in english verb to be is more logical.

updated Nov 12, 2011
edited by xtiagox
posted by xtiagox
nice post. thanks! - billygoat, Nov 12, 2011
Great information!! - 001a2987, Nov 12, 2011
Great examples, Xtiagox! - territurtle, Nov 12, 2011
Thank you so much! - SonrisaDelSol, Nov 12, 2011
5
votes

Well, I guess for the same reason, sonrisita, that you have them in Englishgrin

You are being such a nuisance!

Stop being such a drag!

Siendo así... acepto. ---------- Being things as they are ..I accept this as a fact.

Estás siendo maleducado.---you are being really annoying.

Me siento bien estando contigo.......I feel so good being with you.

Seguía estando en el mismo lugar----the only one where you cannot use the present participle: It was still in the same place

updated Nov 12, 2011
posted by 00494d19
Thank you, Heidi! - SonrisaDelSol, Nov 12, 2011
5
votes

Try doing a google news or book search. There are plenty of examples to choose from like the ones below:

Voy a seguir estando a la altura de las circunstancias”, remarcó Urribarri tras consagrarse nuevamente en la Gobernación


Ahora mismo, estando donde estamos, pensar en un Madrid-Barça, queda lejos


Hay comercios que nunca cierran porque siguen estando presentes en la memoria de la gente


El otro recital se cumplirá en el mismo Liceo Jubilar, mañana sábado al mediodía, estando dedicado a alumnos, familias y vecinos del instituto.


el ambiente sigue siendo inmejorable

updated Nov 12, 2011
posted by Izanoni1
great examples! - billygoat, Nov 12, 2011
Will do, Izanoni, thanks! - SonrisaDelSol, Nov 12, 2011
3
votes

Estás estando tonta. wink

(silly)

updated Nov 12, 2011
edited by Tosh
posted by Tosh
Thank you, Tosh!! Good example! - SonrisaDelSol, Nov 11, 2011
De nada. No fui siendo serio. :). - Tosh, Nov 11, 2011
"estás siendo" - cogumela, Nov 12, 2011
it would be good if it were correct, siendo ...as cogu said already - 00494d19, Nov 12, 2011
Thanks for the correction! I thought it would be estando because you could be silly one day, and not silly the next day. Maybe I'll understand ser/estar one day! :) - Tosh, Nov 12, 2011
2
votes

Siendo así... acepto. ——— Being things as they are ..I accept this as a fact.

Here are a few alternative expressions which might capture the same fatalistic sentiment without being quite so literal:

?Things are how/the way they are...I've just got to deal with it.

?That's just the way things are

?Oh well! That's just the way the cookie crumbles

?Such is life

?Yeah, well, what are you gonna do? –or– What are ya gonna do, eh? (Here the "siendo así part is implied. Also note that the spelling of "ya" and "gonna" are considered nonstandard English)

?It is what it is (the acepto part is generally implied with this statement)

All of these expressions are fairly colloquial (at least in many parts of the U.S.). The last of these ("It is what it is") has been so overused in recent years to the point that it now has almost become a sort of throwaway line.

updated Nov 12, 2011
edited by Izanoni1
posted by Izanoni1
thaks izan, I actually wanted to use the same expression, to show sonrisa that it is as possible in English as in Spanish. I love the cookins one, jeje great - 00494d19, Nov 12, 2011
Another perfectly succinct post, Izanoni! I'm becoming quite a fan of your posts by now!! [Wasn't around earlier, or I would have been a fan earlier. ;) ] - territurtle, Nov 12, 2011
Your posts are always so helpful, Izanoni! - SonrisaDelSol, Nov 12, 2011
2
votes

Hey Sonrisa - That's the kind of random thought I would have. I don't know that I can remember running into estando, but it's fairly common to run into siendo. Of course at this instant I can't remember such an example, but I think you could, for instance, say:

Los niños siguen siendo malos...

Sigo siendo lo mismo...

updated Nov 12, 2011
posted by Jeremias
Gracias, Jeremias! - SonrisaDelSol, Nov 11, 2011