Home
Q&A
they´re their marbles the Juan

they´re their marbles the Juan

4
votes

la palabra "their" se utiliza solo cuando hay mas de dos personas o también cuando hay una, Por ejemplo: Si hay una niña con varios caballos como se dice "they´re her horses " or "they´re their horses". En qué situaciones de respuestas como "Estos son sus caballos" "estos son sus pollos" etc

1591 views
updated Nov 10, 2011
posted by china0102
her - Silvia, Nov 9, 2011

3 Answers

3
votes

Hola China,

El adjetivo de posesión "their" puede significar o su o sus:

Por ejemplo:

She watched their horses - los caballos de ellos, sus caballos.

She watched their horse - el caballo de ellos, su caballo.

El llave es que los que tienen posesión ha de ser en plural.

PERO, tambien puede refier a una persona indefinida:

Whoever called did not leave their number - La persona que llamó no dejó su teléfono.

En este caso nota que "their" es singular, pero refiere a una persona indefinida.

Espero que mi español sea suficientemente claro.

Tambien: Nota que, en tu ejemplo, "they're" no es lo mismo como "their", aunque suena lo mismo. "They're" es una contracción de "they are."

updated Nov 10, 2011
edited by Jeremias
posted by Jeremias
3
votes

they're=hay they're (son, están)

their=(su, sus, de ellos, de ellas)

You do not say their when the antecedent is: she/ella (her) or he/él (his). Their refers to (they/ellos/ellas)

I don't wish to confuse you, but there are usages of they when referring to an anonymous, single person of unknown sex. Only in such a context could their refer to a single person. In other words if we don't know if it is a his or her, sometimes their is used. This is a specialized exception. Their usually is used with two or more people.

Someone left their magazine on the desk. (their is a single anonymous person of unknown sex. We do not know if it is her or his magazine.) But if we do know the person's sex, then their would be incorrect. You do not say, María left their watch on the bathroom sink.

updated Nov 10, 2011
edited by 0074b507
posted by 0074b507
They're = they are, no? Hay = there is, or there are, but there are doesn't become they're. I don't think. :) - Jeremias, Nov 9, 2011
Yes, silly me. There are; not they are (son/están) - 0074b507, Nov 9, 2011
As you know Gfreed, I do that kind of thing all the time... - Jeremias, Nov 9, 2011
1
vote

Then can one say . Los caballos de ella. - Her horses.

Los caballos sus. - Their horses ?

updated Nov 9, 2011
posted by ray76
los caballos suyos.. su, sus can be his/her/ their (and your) as the number depends on the object(s) possessed, not the possessor.(s). - 0074b507, Nov 9, 2011
short form possessive adjective before the noun; long form possessive adjectives follow the noun. - 0074b507, Nov 9, 2011
Thank you Q that helps a lot . - ray76, Nov 9, 2011