Home
Q&A
un cliente se puede elegir el modelo . un cliente puede elegir el modelo .

un cliente se puede elegir el modelo . un cliente puede elegir el modelo .

1
vote

un cliente se puede elegir el modelo . un cliente puede elegir el modelo .

what's the difference between these two sentences? which one is correct? is it concerned about “Dativo de interés”

1296 views
updated Nov 11, 2011
edited by 00494d19
posted by songleishiyulin

3 Answers

1
vote

un cliente se puede elegir el modelo = a client can choose the model by and for himself

un cliente puede elegir el modelo = a client can choose the model

Do you understand this?

If not, then someone with grammar skills should answer.

smile

updated Nov 11, 2011
posted by chileno
0
votes

Hmm... "un cliente se puede elegir el modelo" doesn't sound right to me.

If the verb is being used passively, then there shouldn't be a named actor (cliente).

It sounds like "a client can be chosen the model".... at least to me.

I would say something like "el modelo se puede elegir por un cliente" o "un cliente puede elegir el modelo," like you said.

But my main concern is knowing if "un cliente se puede elegir el modelo" is actually correct. Can someone help?

updated Nov 8, 2011
posted by DonCiro
and if it is correct, is it like saying "a client can choose a model for himself?" - DonCiro, Nov 8, 2011
0
votes

I believe the verb poder here is used in a pronominal construction (poderse) only for emphasis.

You can do it, lo puedes hacer. I can also say, te lo puedes hacer.

Un cliente se puede elegir el modelo should mean something like, a client can choose the model, with emphasis on the ability or on how easily the client can choose.

That's how I understand it but I'm not a native speaker.

updated Nov 8, 2011
posted by macapi