Juan da unos aretes para ellas
1
vote
"juan da unos aretes para ellas " when short it do we say it juan les los da or juan ses los da?? please answer my question
1531 views
updated Nov 1, 2011
edited by --Mariana--
posted by -bestgirl98-
2 Answers
1
vote
"juan da unos aretes para ellas " when short it do we say it juan les los da or juan ses los da??
Neither. It would be: "Juan se los da."
"Se" is always the replacement word whenever you have both a direct object pronoun and an indierect object pronoun that begins with an L.
updated Nov 1, 2011
posted by Goyo
Indirect object pronouns are not needed with por and para. - macapi, Oct 30, 2011
True, but there is no place in any of the above sentences where an indirect object pronoun is used with para or por. - Goyo, Oct 31, 2011
Sure but the short of the above sentence is Juan los da para ellas. - macapi, Nov 1, 2011
1
vote
Juan les da unos aretes a ellas. Juan se los da.
Anyway, No indirect object pronouns with para and por.
updated Nov 1, 2011
edited by macapi
posted by macapi
And you *must* use one for *a ellas*. So it's "Juan les da unos aretes a ellas." - Goyo, Oct 31, 2011
You're right. - macapi, Nov 1, 2011
