Home
Q&A
How would you say: He did it to himself

How would you say: He did it to himself

4
votes

How would you say: He did it to himself I think this refers to Reflexive Verbs. I need some clarification on this please.

4480 views
updated Oct 17, 2011
posted by Acelata
So is "Lo hizo a sí mismo" correct? - Acelata, Oct 16, 2011
And what is "sí " ? - Acelata, Oct 16, 2011

9 Answers

2
votes

Maybe... (él) se lo hizo a sí mismo, but I'm not sure if that sounds natural to a native speaker.

What's it that he did to himself? I'd use the suitable verb that describes what he did to himself and use it reflexively. wink

updated Oct 16, 2011
posted by Elmar
Elmar, I overcomplicated a relativly simple sentence. - annierats, Oct 16, 2011
Since you gave the right answer 1st elmar you get the credit. Buen hecho. I guess in this example 'he' carried a unlicensed gun into a club and it went off and accidentally shot himself. Loosely based on Plaxico Burress Giants football player. LOL - Acelata, Oct 16, 2011
7
votes

So is "Lo hizo a sí mismo" correct?

No it isn't.

Se lo hizo a sí mismo is correct.

updated Oct 16, 2011
posted by cogumela
Yeeeeeeeeeeeeees, I was right! Thank you, Cogu :) - Elmar, Oct 16, 2011
3
votes

Literally translating this would be, Lo hizo a sí mismo, but I bet that it's wrong.

What I am sure about is that it is not reflexive, since se hizo a sí mismo means he's a self-made man.

updated Oct 16, 2011
edited by Eddy
posted by Eddy
It is reflexive. Your second example is pronomial. - Felixlynx, Oct 16, 2011
Not according to Collins it isn't. - Eddy, Oct 16, 2011
1
vote

**: Se hizo hombre de negocisos**

A self-made businessman?

Gracias a mis amigos, creo que ahora tenemos una respuesta correcta.

Photobucket

updated Oct 17, 2011
edited by annierats
posted by annierats
In this case "Se hizo hombre de negocios" - 005faa61, Oct 16, 2011
Gracias, that's what I wrote before doubt set in. Sometimes less is more. - annierats, Oct 16, 2011
1
vote

So why add on "a sí mismo" ?

Not just for emphasis, but also for clarity, because in Spanish: "se lo hizo" can mean many other things, like "he did it for her"

Isn't Se lo hizo sufficient?

Yes, it is, but we'd normally add the "a sí mismo"

What does "a sí mismo" mean?

It means "to himself".


Acelata, would you be so kind as to accept Elmar's answer, please? I feel mine has absolutely no merit, he was the first one to give you the right answer, I've only confirmed his. Thank you smile

updated Oct 16, 2011
posted by cogumela
Con mucho gusto. Por supuesto. - Acelata, Oct 16, 2011
Gracias :) - cogumela, Oct 16, 2011
1
vote

Annierats:

Se lo hizo a sí mismo un hombre de negocios?

It sounds certainly weird. I can't think in a proper translation. We just don't say "a sí mismo", this way. I guess self-made businessman is too idiomatic to be translated.

I think we would just say:

Se hizo un hombre de negocios,

or

Se convirtió en un hombre de negocios.

No reflexivity is perceived here. These mean simply: He became a businessman.

updated Oct 16, 2011
edited by cogumela
posted by cogumela
Yes I agree about the 'lo' there as well, it does look wierd. - Acelata, Oct 16, 2011
Thank you cougumela, I started like that, then got beset by doubts. Muchas gracias, explicas todo muy bien. - annierats, Oct 16, 2011
0
votes

So why add on "a sí mismo" ? Isn't Se lo hizo sufficient? What does "a sí mismo" mean?

Se lo hizo a sí mismo is correct.

updated Oct 16, 2011
posted by Acelata
0
votes

So is "Lo hizo a sí mismo" correct?

updated Oct 16, 2011
posted by Acelata
0
votes

use reflexive tense sir :D

like

me

te

se

nos

=

they did to them selves

updated Oct 16, 2011
posted by gunnerbailey