Home
Q&A
Dreaming In Another Language

Dreaming In Another Language

12
votes

This follows 4annie's thread, "Getting your languages mixed up".

I am now getting my dreams mixed up in so much as I have now started to dream and talk in Spanish. There am I babbling away, sometimes with my family looking on wondering what I am saying, it's so weird.

What's even worse is my wife asking me in the morning, who the hell's Maria?

6931 views
updated Nov 21, 2011
edited by Eddy
posted by Eddy
Great, now you're going to have to explain who Maria is to your second wife as well. ;) jeje - Nicole-B, Oct 1, 2011
Damn, I never thought of that. - Eddy, Oct 1, 2011
:) - Nicole-B, Oct 1, 2011

9 Answers

7
votes

Whenever I wake up from a dream in which I was speaking Spanish I wonder how much of what I was saying was correct. long face

updated Nov 21, 2011
posted by elainepnj
Jaja. Me, too! It all seems perfect in the dream but in reality...now that's something totally different. - Goldie_Miel, Oct 1, 2011
I do the same. Then I wonder if checking my dream dialogues for grammatical errors is bordering on obsessive. jeje - Nicole-B, Oct 1, 2011
jejeje :) I guess the best option is when one of the moderators comes to you in your dream and corrects you :D - PrincessMariam, Oct 1, 2011
Yo también! ;) - territurtle, Oct 2, 2011
4
votes

I have always found this a fascinating topic. I recently had friends staying at my house who were half Dominican and half Norwegian. They live in the D.R., but spend a lot of time in Norway. They are also fairly fluent in English. When asked this question, one said their dreams were usually in Spanish. The other said it varied. I wondered what caused the difference between these two relatives. I guess I'll never know.

I did read this New York Times article which I found interesting:

In the study, of which she was co-author, 552 Texas college students fluent in both Spanish and English were asked about their language preferences for thinking, dreaming and doing mental arithmetic. The researchers found that 78 percent of those who reported doing mental arithmetic in English said they dreamed in English only, and that 54 percent of those who did mental computations in Spanish said they dreamed in Spanish only.

This was a study dealing with bilinguals but I did find it interesting.

updated Oct 2, 2011
edited by Nicole-B
posted by Nicole-B
I normally don't like statistics. Generally half the people are wrong and the other 70% don't know much better. - Eddy, Oct 2, 2011
Good one! jeje - Nicole-B, Oct 2, 2011
4
votes

I've had dreams like this, but in real life I'm not as fluent as I am in my dream!

He tenido sueños así, pero en realidad no hablo con fluidez como en mis sueños.

updated Oct 2, 2011
posted by SusanaEspana
4
votes

Hey, Eddy. I have heard that when you are dreaming in a language you were learning for a long time it means it became fluent for you. Because it is already in your subcnonscious. smile So I can only say:

¡Felicitaciones!

updated Oct 2, 2011
posted by PrincessMariam
Thank you - Eddy, Oct 2, 2011
3
votes

I have often wondered if this was possible.

updated Oct 2, 2011
posted by mesaba123
2
votes

My wife tells me that I say "Heidita" in my sleep. Anyways, I have dreams where I'm translating English words first into Spanish, and then into French. I wonder if any multilingual members of SD have the same experience?

I suspect that I dream this because I am not fluent in either of those two languages and I'm still intent on learning them. My guess is that a truly multilingual person would simply "conceptualize" from one language to another without "thinking" from one word to another. I congratulate Eddy et. al. for these dreams 'cuz it means we're engaged in our learning.

updated Oct 2, 2011
posted by GaryT
No, I can't say that I do...I dream in one language at a time! - drvicente, Oct 2, 2011
2
votes

My dreams in Spanish tend to be very vivid, realistic and usually I am doing something constructive or worthwhile, such as conversing with persons or getting instructions. Sometimes my dreams in English are like that but less often. English dreams tend to deal more with nightmares!

updated Oct 2, 2011
posted by drvicente
Hmmm ... ? - territurtle, Oct 2, 2011
2
votes

Sometimes I dream the random "odd" word in Spanish.


'My subconscious is probably too nervous to "dream too much in Spanish" for fear that the subjunctive-police or the incorrectly-used-pronoun police will be hiding just around the (dream) corner .......


alt text

updated Oct 2, 2011
posted by nonombre
2
votes

When I dream in Spanish I don't know what I am saying. wink wink wink smile

updated Oct 2, 2011
edited by ian-hill
posted by ian-hill
Ian, I don't believe that at all. - Eddy, Oct 1, 2011
Yo tampoco. - territurtle, Oct 2, 2011
¿Qué por no ? - ian-hill, Oct 2, 2011