Home
Q&A
why "i am hungry" is "tengo hambre" instead of "estoy hambre" ?

why "i am hungry" is "tengo hambre" instead of "estoy hambre" ?

2
votes

"i am hungry" is "tengo hambre" i am eating is "estoy comiendo" are"estoy" and "tengo" same ? confused

46275 views
updated Feb 29, 2012
posted by atz91
Welcome to the forum. - Eddy, Sep 26, 2011

7 Answers

0
votes

You can say "estoy hambriento/a".

updated Sep 26, 2011
posted by pescador1
But that connotes a level of starvation bordering on malnutrition and disease, I think. Not what you want to express here. - pesta, Sep 26, 2011
7
votes

Why should we be correct and the Spanish wrong. I bet there are countless Spanish students saying,

Why is it "I am hungry" and not "I have hunger".

And no, estoy and tengo are not the same, it's just the way both languages express the fact that a person is hungry in a diffrent manner.

updated Feb 29, 2012
posted by Eddy
I had not thought of that. We are all wrong. In fact I have hunger right now, so I´m going to lunch. - tc84, Sep 26, 2011
2
votes

As one of my Spanish teachers once shouted, "There is no why! That's just the way they say it!".

Every language is different. The fact that they have so many similarities is what is amazing, not their differences.

updated Sep 26, 2011
posted by KevinB
1
vote

Well, I have hunger is what it literally says. This is an idiomatic expression. Also estoy and tengo are not the same.

updated Sep 26, 2011
posted by ramthor
1
vote

I can't answer as to why, or how it started, but in Spanish saying "estoy hambre" translates to something like I am hunger or some other nonsensical thing like that. Same goes for hunger, thirst, cold, heat, etc. There are a plethora of other threads that deal with this topic. If you search "estoy vs. tengo" you can find previous posts on this topic.

updated Sep 26, 2011
posted by tc84
0
votes

But that connotes a level of starvation bordering on malnutrition and disease, I think. Not what you want to express here. - pesta = Sep 26, 2011


So "hambriento/a" is rarely used in everyday speech? Unless you are referring to "starving people?" If one is truly hungry, then me estoy muriendo de hambre should suffice? Just curious, compañeros de estudios...


enter image description here

updated Feb 29, 2012
posted by cristalino
0
votes

Because its not "i am hunger" (estoy hambre) but rather "I have hunger" (yo tengo hambre). Unless your name is hunger.... tongue rolleye

updated Sep 26, 2011
posted by Csm007
Then it would be... soy Hambre. :) - Tosh, Sep 26, 2011