Home
Q&A
Do either of these seem awkward?

Do either of these seem awkward?

1
vote

I was watching a TV show, and one of the characters was watching for trespassers. Upon seeing some, he said to his boss "They seem to have entered the building."

I first thought that in Spanish, it would be

"Parece que han entrado el edificio" but I then realized that that would be more along the lines of "It seems that they have entered."

Would it make more sense for me to say

"Parecen haber entrado el edificio" ?

Thanks

1349 views
updated Sep 8, 2011
posted by mayodude
"Does either ..." would be better. - samdie, Sep 7, 2011

3 Answers

3
votes

I think that both mean the same, actually you get the same feeling when you spell out both of these sentences, but you must add :en el edificio: in both cases.

updated Sep 7, 2011
posted by leouna
Yup. Same, same. - samdie, Sep 7, 2011
1
vote

Yo diría:

Parece que han entrado en el edificio.

updated Sep 8, 2011
posted by LuisCache
claro, wow, another 10k candidate, enhorabuena:) - 00494d19, Sep 7, 2011
Muchas gracias, Heidita. Saludos. - LuisCache, Sep 8, 2011
0
votes

I agree with Luis.

What you are saying is that you no longer see them, so it appears (you surmise) as if they entered the building.

To use some silly hyperbolie....let's assume the building is full of dust in the air. When you see the two people covered in dust, then you would say... they appear to have entered by building...judging from their change in their appearance; not the fact that you can no longer see them.

updated Sep 7, 2011
edited by 0074b507
posted by 0074b507