Home
Q&A
What age is best for learning a new language?

What age is best for learning a new language?

3
votes

i've heard it's easier as a child...

3839 views
updated Aug 31, 2011
posted by rockfordrocks
See Jack's response. That old urban legend died decades ago! - territurtle, Aug 30, 2011

17 Answers

18
votes

Anytime before you're dead is good. It doesn't matter when you start, you can learn at any age.

updated Aug 30, 2011
posted by rodneyp
Hahahahaha great answer! - SpanishPal, Aug 29, 2011
Right on rodney. - heliotropeman, Aug 29, 2011
I just had to vote this one up! - Jack-OBrien, Aug 29, 2011
Me too! - MLucie, Aug 29, 2011
¡Perfecta respuesta, Rodney! - territurtle, Aug 29, 2011
and me! - patch, Aug 30, 2011
Hilarious any time before youré dead hahahahha very funny and clever :) - FELIZ77, Aug 30, 2011
9
votes

....I've heard something like said before, not sure who said it....

The best time to start learning was when you were a child. The second best time is now. smile

updated Aug 30, 2011
posted by 001a2987
Good, Chris! - MLucie, Aug 29, 2011
¡Impresionante! - territurtle, Aug 30, 2011
8
votes

Well -

When is the best time to plant a tree?

Answer - about 30 years ago.

A similar idea could be said about learning a language.

In other words "the sooner the better!

updated Aug 30, 2011
posted by ian-hill
very nice :) - Izanoni1, Aug 30, 2011
6
votes

Yes, children exposed to languages at an earlier age learn faster. Well ,now that we're all older ,what is there to do but study harder. If it takes a little longer it's still worth. I'm old and only been learning Spanish for 11 months. I think rodneyp has got it right .I'm not dead yet. Buena suerte.

updated Aug 30, 2011
edited by heliotropeman
posted by heliotropeman
6
votes

How old are you ? That's probably the best age ....

updated Aug 30, 2011
posted by pcirino100
¡Una maravillosa respuesta! - territurtle, Aug 29, 2011
4
votes

Children don't learn any faster. Studies have long ago debunked that theory. In an adult has the exact same level and type of immersion, with the same lack of responsibility and distractions as a child, they will learn at the same pace. Of course, achieving that level of immersion is almost impossible.

updated Aug 30, 2011
posted by Jack-OBrien
Not that impossible for some. Send your 16 y.o. child to a foreign country for a year, and the school will give all the immersion he/she requires. Before the year is over, he/she will be fluent. - lazarus1907, Aug 30, 2011
An adult can indeed learn much faster, although getting a perfect accent is more difficult. - lazarus1907, Aug 30, 2011
3
votes

Any age but mine right now ! sick

updated Aug 30, 2011
posted by ray76
Aw, come on Ray, you soar above me!! - territurtle, Aug 29, 2011
I am "sorely " tempted to accept your compliments , but I know that I am a fraud , it is one of the hardest , albeit interesting and happy things I have done , or rather am attempting to do. - ray76, Aug 30, 2011
But I only jest , I love trying and it is not that hard one just has to dig in and keep at it , and use every means at ones disposal. - ray76, Aug 30, 2011
2
votes

The younger the better Ideally, in a formal way, from about the age of 9 or 10 years old but younger children can enjoy learning languages informally through games and songs from around the age of 3 years old, and even younger children are still listening, absorbing and imitating their parents and siblings from the time they can create sounds.

We learn our native language/mother tongue informally, first, through the medium of our family, then many children go to nursery/playgroup, and later we learn to develop our vocabulary and understanding of how to use language at school. During all this time we depend on the signficant adults in our lives to correct us and above all, provide us with as good a working model of how to use language as possible!

When I used to work as a teaching assistant in the infant department of a busy primary school I encountered young children; many who had English as a second language. They came from diverse countries such as Spain, France, Brazil, Uruguay, Mexico and various parts of Africa and Asia. Many of these children would be learning to speak at least two languages, including their mother tongue, some three languages, and they would be succeeding in doing so. Some bright children could speak better English than children for whom it was their native language

The point that I am making using examples is that the ideal time to learn is during early childhood when the brain is still continuing to grow and develop. Many adults have not had the opportunity to do so and for them therefore I would say start as soon as possible, while your motivation to learn is still strong! It will probably take you considerably longer to learn and become proficient in speaking, understanding writing and reading the language but, be patient with yourself and don't give up and you will reach your own top level which will be different from another person's top level; as our own potential will differ from that of other people.

I hope this helps wink smile grin

updated Aug 30, 2011
edited by FELIZ77
posted by FELIZ77
2
votes

I learned Hungarian from age 2, English from age 4, Spanish from age 14 (and again recently), German from age 19, Italian from age 40.

I don't remember learning my first two - they just "happened".

When I learned German, it caused me to forget most of what Spanish I learned.

When I studied Italian, German phrases kept popping into my head.

Last year, in a restaurant while vacationing in Panama, I asked for "ein vaso de agua" red face

I'm enjoying Spanish, possibly helped by an earlier exposure (even though that early study was a coerced school requirement and I wasn't very motivated).

I don't know that my learning is any slower than when I was younger. It's an apples-to-oranges comparison: When I was 2 years old, I was immersed in my target language and had nothing much better to do all day than babble.... smile

updated Aug 30, 2011
posted by pesta
Pesta, I never knew you spoke Hungarian like Porcupine!! And I love your tale about "ein vaso!" ;)) - territurtle, Aug 30, 2011
I go to a small Spanish class. One day I did abeautiful transllation.My fellow students looked blank. I repeated, slowly and carefully. They looked at me oddly. Suddenly, I realized I was translating into Swedish. The brain had somehow jumped backa step. - annierats, Aug 30, 2011
Form me easy to speak hungarian because I have lived, and still living in Budapest, Hungary - porcupine7, Aug 30, 2011
I'm really glad I've discovered this site, it's full of totally amazing people. - annierats, Aug 30, 2011
2
votes

rodneyp said

Anytime before you're dead is good

Does this mean that foreign languages cease to exist in heaven?

Edit:

I assume that's where I'm destined to end up.

updated Aug 30, 2011
edited by Eddy
posted by Eddy
No, I think Heaven must be where I gain instant fluency in all languages, including Finish and Hungarian! ;) - territurtle, Aug 30, 2011
Yesd, and in hell they change the language, just when you started to understand the Hungarian everybody else huddle up in the sauna whispering about you in Swahili. - annierats, Aug 30, 2011
Good idea. There was an old hungarian/székely/ chap in Romania he was studiiing hebrew. When he was asked why, the anwer was , in the heaven that is the language. What if you should go to hell. I know already romanian. - porcupine7, Aug 30, 2011
You can understand the above, if you know the east european circumstances - porcupine7, Aug 30, 2011
2
votes

Generally children do not learn from books , but from their pals, playing. Therefore it is easier. Otherwise in any age you can learn, but in old age , you are learnig more slowly , and you forget more easily. I suppose the main difference is the prononciation, because children can pick up the perfect prononciation, the older not.

Generalmente los niños no estudian de libros, sino de compañeros, jugandos. Por esto lo parece más facil. Por lo demás, hombre puede estudiar en cualquiera edad, pero en la edad vieja , puedes estudiar más lentamente e olvidar más rápido.

Supongo la más grande diferencia es la pronunciación, porque los niños pueden coger la articulación perfecta, los viejos no.

updated Aug 30, 2011
posted by porcupine7
I agree but most of my "Pals " are either heading for the last roundup or have achieved it. - ray76, Aug 30, 2011
Tu compatriota, Kató Lomb, que hablaba 16 idiomas, no estaría de acuerdo contigo. Léete su Egy tizenhat nyelvű tolmács feljegyzései (in English: http://www.tesl-ej.org/books/lomb-2nd-Ed.pdf) - lazarus1907, Aug 30, 2011
What a joy and thrill it was to learn about Kató Lomb!! - territurtle, Aug 30, 2011
It is a pleasure to read her book, she was very witty and full of understanding - porcupine7, Aug 30, 2011
1
vote

42...

updated Aug 31, 2011
posted by afowen
isn't that the meaning of life? - patch, Aug 30, 2011
Doh! Right answer, wrong question! - afowen, Aug 31, 2011
1
vote

In answer to Eddy's comment, I fear that in hell the temperature is -40C and you have to learn Finnish. As for learning later in life, remember, it's perfectly possible to write without an accent.

updated Aug 30, 2011
posted by annierats
Below/-40C? I doubt it from what Jesus teaches iin the bible ts more likely to be above 40o C! - FELIZ77, Aug 30, 2011
1
vote

In my opinion children are not embarrassed to speak another language and other children won't correct them. Adults might correct their language, but then child are used to being corrected by the parents anyway. That is what I find much more difficult about learning Spanish now, I'm reluctant to speak it. But I didn't care when I was learning Afrikaans as a child.

updated Aug 30, 2011
posted by ShayWest
1
vote

Any age is fine, it's all up to your motivation and attitude.

Never let the "age" factor hinder you, age is only a number.

updated Aug 30, 2011
posted by timsan