Home
Q&A
"yo te estoy dando a ti una caja"

"yo te estoy dando a ti una caja"

2
votes

In this phrase, which I believe says "I am giving a box to you", what does "ti" represent?

2889 views
updated Aug 22, 2011
posted by tyhall

4 Answers

2
votes

It's redundant, for emphasis I would guess. "A ti" is "to you".

updated Aug 22, 2011
posted by LaBurra
1
vote

a ti = to you

te= indirect object pronoun for "a ti" wink

The a ti is unecessary here because you already have the "te"; it just emphasizes that the box is being given to you wink. The "te" is required however (see the reference article on indirect object pronouns for more information)

http://www.spanishdict.com/answers/100017/indirect-object-pronouns

updated Aug 22, 2011
edited by Austin67427
posted by Austin67427
1
vote

it is to specify that the box is being given to you not to someone else, possibly to stress that you are not to give it to anyone else, or that you had asked for it specifically... In english it might sound like "I am giving the box to you alone" (no body else is going to get this box from me)

updated Aug 22, 2011
edited by toothpastechica
posted by toothpastechica
1
vote

It just emphasizes that the box is being given to you probably excluding others. In English we have to express that emphasis with tone of voice. It also allows Spanish to have a written mechanism to convey it. (where we would have to bold or italicize the word, etc.)

I am giving you the box.

updated Aug 22, 2011
edited by 0074b507
posted by 0074b507