Home
Q&A
could you help me proofread my English mistakes ? Topic Sentences 2

could you help me proofread my English mistakes ? Topic Sentences 2

3
votes

In this topic sentence, my teacher told me that this sentence is too general, why?

In my opinion, living in your home town brings back nice childhood memories.

Thanks.

2070 views
updated Aug 16, 2011
posted by maylegoas

3 Answers

1
vote

Hi, the sentence is perfect in English.

Did you have a specific assignment where you had to write about your personal experience?

updated Aug 16, 2011
posted by --Mariana--
1
vote

In my opinion, living in your home town brings back nice childhood memories.

I believe it is a too general because you don't say what type of memories.

Also, the word "nice" is a bit generic.

Words to use instead of nice/good: excellent; superior, fine, wonderful, life-changing, genuine, devine, beneficial, wonderful, lovely, perfect, incredible

May I suggest a revision?

1) In my opinion, living in your home town is reminder of the childhood experiences you still remember to this day.

2) In my opinion, living in your home town will remind you of memories that slipped from your mind long ago.

3) In my opinion, living in your home town brings back childhood memories that have continued to shape your personality to this day.

updated Aug 16, 2011
edited by SonrisaDelSol
posted by SonrisaDelSol
Is this topic sentences too specific? - maylegoas, Aug 16, 2011
Sorry, I wanted say: Is those topic sentences too specific? - maylegoas, Aug 16, 2011
Careful: **Are** those...not **is** those; I don't think they are too specific. If you want the least specific one, I think the first one would be the best choice. - SonrisaDelSol, Aug 16, 2011
1
vote

Your teacher may be looking for more discriptive words. Nice is a pretty broad word, maybe if you said memories of great fun or remindes you of the things you enjoyed as a kid.

If the excersise was designed to use discriptive words I would see why the teacher might not like the word nice, it is a very broad and general word. This link has lots of different discriptive words to choose from and to get to know:

Descriptive words

updated Aug 16, 2011
edited by SonrisaDelSol
posted by toothpastechica
hmm thats interesting...the link button isn't working - toothpastechica, Aug 16, 2011
I can't get it to work either. - --Mariana--, Aug 16, 2011
Hola, toothpaste! I fixed your link for you :D - SonrisaDelSol, Aug 16, 2011
thank you! - toothpastechica, Aug 16, 2011