Home
Q&A
por or para

por or para

4
votes

Is it correct to use por when saying something is by someone?...por ejemplo: la cancion es por/para Juanes.

1622 views
updated Aug 3, 2011
posted by OVNI

6 Answers

5
votes

Are you saying the song is written or performed by Juanes?

Typically, in these cases, por is not enough.

La canción fué escrita por Juanes.

La canción fué interpretada por Juanes or Juanes interpreta la canción, etc.

updated Aug 3, 2011
posted by 005faa61
Cierto :) - 00a4c226, Aug 3, 2011
3
votes

Use ''por'' to say it's written by Juan. smile

And use ''para'' to say it's written for Juan!

updated Aug 3, 2011
edited by 00b6f46c
posted by 00b6f46c
2
votes

You have to use "por" for "by", meaning Juanes wrote the song. Para would mean the song was written for Juanes as the recipient.

updated Aug 3, 2011
posted by lorenzo9
2
votes

I would say "por" is correct. Like "la cancion es por Juanes, el libro fué escrito por Paulo Coelho, la obra fué pintada por Botero, etc".

updated Aug 3, 2011
posted by 00a4c226
1
vote

Another thing you might think about, if you are saying it is by (as in created or writen)the artist I believe you could use "de". For example, "de quien es esa canción? es de Maná." That might however indicate ownership than authorship, which is probably true, but perhaps not the intended sentiment.

Batanga.com the Spanish internet radio site that I listen to uses "por."

updated Aug 3, 2011
posted by tc84
Estás en lo cierto, una canción es *de* alguien o escrita *por* alguien. Para no se aplica aquí. - Deanski, Aug 3, 2011
0
votes

The link where this is explained in detail is here

updated Aug 3, 2011
edited by Zoltán
posted by Zoltán