Home
Q&A
Quedar -vs- Estar

Quedar -vs- Estar

4
votes

I just heard that it is common to use "estar" for the location of objects, and "quedar" for the location of places.

¿Dónde está mi otro calcetín?

¿Dónde queda la tienda?

Is what I heard correct?

12813 views
updated Jul 2, 2011
posted by Tosh
Good question Tom :) - EL_MAG0, Jul 2, 2011

5 Answers

3
votes

Lazarus's explanation makes it clear to me now.

"Quedar" can also mean "to remain" - very close to "to be situated".

The location of a store is permanent, situated, remaining... compared to the location of a sock, which will change once you find it.

"está" could be used in both of my examples... but you probably wouldn't use "queda" in both of them.

However I could combine them:

¿Dónde queda la tienda de calcetines? smile

updated Jul 2, 2011
edited by Tosh
posted by Tosh
3
votes

Quedar means "to be situated".

updated Jul 2, 2011
posted by lazarus1907
Good answer Lazarus - EL_MAG0, Jul 2, 2011
Gracias amigo - bert1929, Jul 2, 2011
1
vote

¿Dónde está mi otro calcetín?

¿Dónde queda la tienda?

Are these sentences correct?

I agree with the first one, but I think the second one would use "está". Can someone explain?

updated Jul 2, 2011
edited by SonrisaDelSol
posted by SonrisaDelSol
"está" could be used in both, but "queda" is correct in the 2nd sentence as well. It depicts "la tienda" as a more permanent location (as compared to the location of a sock). - Tosh, Jul 2, 2011
Ok, that makes sense. Gracias - SonrisaDelSol, Jul 2, 2011
0
votes

The location of a store is permanent, situated, remaining... compared to the location of a sock, which will change once you find it.

"está" could be used in both of my examples... but you probably wouldn't use "queda" in both of them.

Actually, you can use "queda" in both examples but with the "quedarse" form in the sock example. When we misplace a sock, many times we put the blame on the sock to avoid feeling like an idiot, so we say in past tense "¿Donde se quedó mi calcetín?" puttng the responsibility completely on the sock itself (the sock put itself in its place unknown to you).

updated Jul 2, 2011
edited by 005faa61
posted by 005faa61
Julián, "quedó" and "se quedó" are not quite the same, which is why they are explained separately in dictionaries. - lazarus1907, Jul 2, 2011
0
votes

All is fine, however, you can also ask "¿Dónde está la tienda?", you know.

grin

updated Jul 2, 2011
posted by chileno