Home
Q&A
Using the infinitive of a reflexive verb after some form of Poder

Using the infinitive of a reflexive verb after some form of Poder

1
vote

In English, the sentence reads: "Good people are able to defend themselves."

In Spanish, I make this:

"Buenas personas (o la gente buena, tal vez) pueden defenderse"

Thank you for your assistance; I hate dreaming about these things! Perdone! I included the "la gente buena" only as an alternative to "Buenas personas" ... My question is really about using "defenderse" or any other reflexive verb in this way. Many thanks for all your comments! alt text

4757 views
updated May 21, 2011
edited by Lector_Constante
posted by Lector_Constante

5 Answers

0
votes

"la buena gente puede defenderse" the first one is correct.

updated May 20, 2011
edited by GuitarWarrior
posted by GuitarWarrior
To me is plain wrong without an article. - lazarus1907, May 20, 2011
I concur with Laz. - 002067fe, May 20, 2011
I thought I put that there. What is wrong with me!? - GuitarWarrior, May 20, 2011
2
votes

Maybe it is just me, but without the article the sentence sounds completely wrong:

La gente buena tiene la habilidad de defenderse.

"Buena gente" is correct, but it is not quite the same. I am open to debate on this one.

updated May 20, 2011
posted by lazarus1907
I agree. "Buena gente" isn't 'wrong', but it's just a tad off in this context. And yes, it needs the article. - 002067fe, May 20, 2011
2
votes

"Good people are able to defend themselves."

La gente buena es capaz de defenderse.

updated May 20, 2011
posted by 002067fe
I'm glad to see I'm not the only one on this. Thanks, Tom! - lazarus1907, May 20, 2011
1
vote

Isn't "buena gente" a folksy, colloquial term, more commonly used when you talk about a particular person who is nice, and sort of naive? (Mario es demasiado buena gente)

I have always understood that "good people" is "la gente buena". (although I have heard folks from the Southern US say "I love him, he is good people")

updated May 20, 2011
posted by Oramasdude
That's true, but in "Mario es buena gente", that "buena gente" is a nominal object, not a subject, like in the main clause. Different rules apply. - lazarus1907, May 20, 2011
Gracias. - Oramasdude, May 20, 2011
0
votes

Your translation is fine.

If you wanted use the exact words of the English text, you could also say "Buena gente tiene la habilidad de defenderse."

updated May 20, 2011
posted by 005faa61
!!! - lazarus1907, May 20, 2011