Home
Q&A
When is "e" used instead of "y" for "and"?

When is "e" used instead of "y" for "and"?

2
votes

Is it only when the word following "y" begins with an "i"?

So, NOT... Voy a trabajar con Jane y Irene.

But instead... Voy a trabajar con Jane e Irene.

Any other reasons? Any other examples?

9439 views
updated May 17, 2011
edited by Tosh
posted by Tosh

4 Answers

6
votes

This from the net smile

Y becomes e when it precedes a word that begins with the i sound, while o becomes u when it precedes a word that begins with the o sound. Typically, then, the y becomes e when it precedes most words that begin with i- or hi-, and o becomes u preceding words starting with o- or ho-. Y does not change before words, such as hierba, that begin with the y sound, regardless of spelling.

updated May 17, 2011
posted by Kiwi-Girl
Hi MC! - 005faa61, May 16, 2011
1
vote

To facilitate pronunciation, "E" replaces "Y" when the word preceeds a word with an "I" sound such as "indio," "hijo,"invocar," idioma," "hipódromo," etc.

updated May 16, 2011
posted by 005faa61
"...precedes..." - 002067fe, May 16, 2011
0
votes

¡Gracias! Yo no s?u?p?e? sabía acerca de la "o".

In principle you could use either verb, but "sabía" is more likely here. Another thing is your "yo" -you only use it if you are making a contrast, such as "He knew it, but I didn't know it" (he vs. I). If you use it like that, we'd be wondering who are the other ones you are comparing yourself against.

updated May 17, 2011
posted by lazarus1907
Tom told me to add it. See the comment above. I didn't have it at first, honest!! Lol. - Tosh, May 17, 2011
0
votes

¡Gracias! Yo no s?u?p?e? sabía acerca de la "o".

Please correct my wording if it is incorrect.

updated May 17, 2011
edited by Tosh
posted by Tosh
I'm not 100% sure on this but I have read that no sabía = I didn't know, no supe = I didn't find out - hopefully Tom or Julian are still around :) - Kiwi-Girl, May 16, 2011
to say for sure :) - Kiwi-Girl, May 16, 2011
Yep. ¿Carmen u Oscar? ¿Carlos u Horacio? - 002067fe, May 16, 2011
Yep, KiwiGirl is correct, you should have written "Yo no sabía [eso] acerca de la 'o' ." - 002067fe, May 16, 2011
So the imperfect instead of the past in this case? - Tosh, May 16, 2011
Fixed. But why the personal pronoun? Every other time I get my hand slapped for using it. ;) - Tosh, May 16, 2011
In this case, it's not totally necessary, but I would not say it is horribly wrong and that you must be punished for using it. - 002067fe, May 16, 2011
Just don't let Heidi see it lol, or yep, you got it, dunce corner for you :) - Kiwi-Girl, May 17, 2011