Home
Q&A
Why such a desire to judge it as easy or difficult?

Why such a desire to judge it as easy or difficult?

15
votes

Recently, I have seen a lot of posts about this. Everybody is asking the reason why Spanish or English is so difficult to write, to understand, to pronounce... Why should it be easy? A language is not something that one single brain can invent by itself. The rules, the fact that they don't have a rule, the conjugation, idioms... All these things are a part of it being in certain order.

Of course, the connection with the language spoken by a person can change the difficulty level, but it's never easy nor difficult. I'm tired of seeing questions like "Is there an easy way to...." The only answer to those questions is: if you are asking it, there is no easy way for you. If it were easy, you would see it already.

I never judge languages. But yes, I say: "Well, I can understand a lot of French sentences." Because I am familiar with some words just because I speak English, Spanish and Turkish. Saying simply "in the country x it's more difficult to understand people" doesn't make any sense. It depends on a lot of things but the country itself. What is the problem? The fact that some Spanish people pronounce the letter c lispily? Okay, now you know that they do. From now on it's not that difficult at all, is it? Or the fact that in Argentina they use "vos" for the personal pronoun "you" instead of "tú"... One can learn saying "vos" as easily as they do with "tú".

So, what I want to say is, is there an explanation for this passion that I don't know of?

3068 views
updated Apr 22, 2011
edited by culé
posted by culé
well said, and well thought out. - nike907, Apr 21, 2011

13 Answers

10
votes

In answer to the last sentence of your question, yes there is a reason for this.

I can't speak for other English speaking nations, but in England the level of language education (including our very own!) is extremely poor. I honestly do not personally know of one single English person who can fluently speak a foreign language. Unlike many of the other European countries, it seems, we are not properly taught languages. Indeed I'm embarrassed at times to admit that my English too really is poor. In fact by trying to learn Spanish, I had to first learn what a noun, pronoun, verb etc was!! Honest I am not joking here!

English people hear foreign people speaking excellent English all the time! So, perhaps, we start to think to ourselves.........."well if others can learn excellent English, is there is catch to this? You know, any techniques etc that we can try to grasp and use in our learning"??

I am not lazy, I want to learn Spanish because at some stage in my life I want to part-live there. I have tried night school classes and to be quite frank they have been extremely poor. Therefore, I have been teaching myself for about the last 8 months. I am spending perhaps 4 or 5 hours a day on average trying to learn the language. I am really happy with my progress and am really enjoying the experience. I've found this site to be an extremely useful source of help and inspiration at times. However, I can honestly understand why some English people may think there is a particular technique (or easy) way to learn. For me though, I will plod along and enjoy the ride grin

updated Apr 21, 2011
posted by billygoat
What a wonderful post! - Sabor, Apr 21, 2011
Ditto, nice post. You speak for a lot of us billygoat! No "kiddin' - GaryT, Apr 21, 2011
In defence of the English I can only say that it is an Island. In the past we couldn not listen to French TV because it was a different system - ian-hill, Apr 21, 2011
A N D our language teaching methods are awful. - ian-hill, Apr 21, 2011
Congratulations on your enthusiasm and hard work. YOU CAN DO IT! Just keep plodding along, you'll soon have new friends and new culture to enjoy! - nike907, Apr 21, 2011
Best reply anybody can think of! Nice! I do hate the feeling I get though when I talk to someone in English (American English) so perfectly like they live here, and find out they are in a non-english speaking country, and they are in a grade lower than me - el_jefe, Apr 21, 2011
because the language teaching here isn't that great either, it's nice but not as good as in Sweden. - el_jefe, Apr 21, 2011
6
votes

Culé, I have never asked a question like the ones you are talking about because I already know the answer (No!). But in my fantasy world I would take a pill and wake up tomorrow using all the object pronouns and subjunctive tenses and other things I haven't even thought about yet. Maybe people are hoping for a hint, thinking there might be some secret besides hard work. Nobody really likes hard work very much.

I think Billygoat has the best idea and the most realistic attitude. No fantasy for him.

For me though, I will plod along and enjoy the ride.

updated Apr 22, 2011
posted by Sabor
lol thank you Sabor. Other than Spanish, the rest of my life is a fantasy :P - billygoat, Apr 21, 2011
"the subjunctive mood" (the tense inflections are no more complicated than for the indicative, the only problem is when to use the subjunctive mood). - samdie, Apr 21, 2011
If you happen to find this pill, please please please let me know where you found it!! jejeje - 001a2987, Apr 21, 2011
Visited Medellin last weekend. Donated blood But, the joke was: next week there will be a Colombiano who's magically speaking American English because he/she's got a 1/2 liter of gringo blood. Could be the 'magic pill'. Thanks for your participation! - nike907, Apr 21, 2011
5
votes

You responded to my question about whether it is easier for someone who is learning Spanish to understand spoken Spanish in some countries/regions/etc. than in others with a similar, seemingly annoyed response. I understand that there will always be inherent difficulties in trying to understand anything new. I was not looking for some magical way around that. I was simply wondering if the pronunciation in certain places would be easier to understand for someone who is learning Spanish. For example, I have heard speakers from certain places regularly leave the endings off of words when they speak. For someone who is learning Spanish, I think this can be very difficult to understand because someone who is not fluent in a language must really focus on every sound that he or she hears in order to understand what is being said. So if some of the sounds of a word are left off in speech, it can be very difficult to guess what someone is saying. That is all I was referring to.

updated Apr 22, 2011
posted by arh1
No worries, I am not annoyed. Maybe your question was a trigger to this. :) - culé, Apr 21, 2011
The thing is, how can you possibly judge that obectively? What's easier to understand for a learner: English from London, English from Sydney, from Belfast, from Bombay, from Jamaica? Kentucky, perhaps, or The Bronx? Ontario or Guyana? Someone who takes - Gekkosan, Apr 21, 2011
English lessons in Oxford may find herself perfectly comfortable with the accent from Barbados, or New Zealand, but may feel completely lost in South Carolina. Likewise someone who learns the accent used in US TV probably will feel lost in Cambridge - Gekkosan, Apr 21, 2011
5
votes

I judge that this question is very difficult, and that makes me unhappy. I think you should restrict youself to easy questions, such as "¿cómo se dice Te amo en inglés?"

My life is complicated enough as it is! smile

updated Apr 21, 2011
edited by Gekkosan
posted by Gekkosan
Jejeje, pues, lo siento hombre. Por cierto ¿cómo se dice eso en inglés? - culé, Apr 21, 2011
Funny. You now voice another equally common complaint. :) - pesta, Apr 21, 2011
You deserve a vote Gekko for making me laugh hahaha:) - FELIZ77, Apr 21, 2011
4
votes

I don't think people believe that there's a magic way to learn a new language. When this ask "What's an easy way to...." they simply want to know the best or most efficient way to conquer a difficult task.

For example: Someone washing a floor with a toothbrush may ask "Is there an easier way to do this?", so you hand them a mop, and make their lives a bit easier.

The same applies to beginners in Spanish.

updated Apr 22, 2011
posted by Felixlynx
Good principle which usually works well provided that teh questioner is intelligent and being realistic about how they expect to learn a language. - FELIZ77, Apr 21, 2011
For example if you were to show an intelligent person a better way to do something they would want to change to a more effective method but present teh same idea to someone who is proud or not as intelligent and they would rather to stick to - FELIZ77, Apr 21, 2011
their old way even if that meant it was as ineffective and time consuming as washing the kitchen floor with a toothbrush - FELIZ77, Apr 21, 2011
Of course, no rule applies everytime. I just don't believe people should scorn those who want a better way to do something.. - Felixlynx, Apr 21, 2011
.. because those who want to have a better way to do something, are those that find them, and are those that have shaped the world. - Felixlynx, Apr 21, 2011
If no one had ever asked "Is there an easier way to do this?", then we'd still be living in caves, with sticks - Felixlynx, Apr 21, 2011
3
votes

Nicely written, Culé!

The only answer I can come up with is that the people wanting the learning process to be easy are basically lazy.

updated Apr 22, 2011
posted by 005faa61
3
votes

¿Por qué no puedes hacer una repuesta facíl, como lo demás? tongue laugh

Me gusta tu mensaje.

updated Apr 22, 2011
edited by pesta
posted by pesta
3
votes

I was simply wondering if the pronunciation in certain places would be easier to understand for someone who is learning Spanish. For example, I have heard speakers from certain places regularly leave the endings off of words when they speak. For someone who is learning Spanish, I think this can be very difficult to understand because someone who is not fluent in a language must really focus on every sound that he or she hears in order to understand what is being said. So if some of the sounds of a word are left off in speech, it can be very difficult to guess what someone is saying.

I haven´t seen your original question, but you make a good point here. For eample, if you are in Cuba, Venezuela, DR, PR, etc learning the language, then the "eating the Ss" and other sloppy pronunciations won´t be a problem because this is how you will always hear the language being spoken. But if you are not in a Spanish-speaking country and you are studying the language by taking a proper course, then yes, it can be difficult to understand the Carribean pronunciation.

I once saw a Cuban film with a Mexican friend in the USA, and afterwards he told me he had to read the English subtitles to understand it. And his English skills were not very advanced at that time.

updated Apr 21, 2011
edited by 005faa61
posted by 005faa61
Thank you for that, Julian - Sabor, Apr 21, 2011
I knew somebody that was watching a Jamaicab movie subtitled in English and he said he didn't realize they were speaking English until halfway through. - lorenzo9, Apr 21, 2011
2
votes

I have seen several examples of people asking questions on here, and getting angry responses about them asking the question. Seriously, I am not picking on anyone. I don't understand the anger. Why not just click on another question and ignore the ones you don't like?

Sometimes I get the impression that there is some great loss if a question is asked that someone has asked before. I am not specifically speaking to you as the poster of this question. I love it when someone posts a link, or directs the questioner to previous posts that answer the question.

I am glad you asked this because it is of interest to me, and I can get a feel for what others think about this by reading the answers.

updated Apr 22, 2011
posted by dc-alien-z
I think people's moods are affected by what is going on in their real life. - lorenzo9, Apr 21, 2011
Good point Lorenzo:) - FELIZ77, Apr 21, 2011
How do I ask "this isn't real life?" so you know my tongue is stuck in my cheek? haha Never mind, I think I did it. - dc-alien-z, Apr 21, 2011
dcalienz, thank you so much for making these statements! I too, do not understand why someone gets so annoyed when a question is asked, that has been asked before.. perhaps 2 years ago! This IS a learning website after all! Gracias! - Gillygaloo, Apr 21, 2011
Some questions get asked that are worth repeating. Some get asked just about every other day "why el agua and not la agua?", and really, what more can be said about that subject? There are two tools I very much believe in showing newcommers: - Gekkosan, Apr 21, 2011
the translation tool, and the search box. IF the answers you find do not satisfy your particular variant of a question, then by all means ask away. I am always delighted when someone finds a way to make an old, common, answered-to-death question sound - - Gekkosan, Apr 21, 2011
interesting again. I appreciate people showing intelligence and ingenuity. Those people rarely ask the same obvious question that already has a thousand replies. - Gekkosan, Apr 21, 2011
You are indeed helpful, as many on here are. Also you often display a sense of humor. I need to laugh sometimes. - dc-alien-z, Apr 21, 2011
One thing I discovered early in my language teaching "career" is that a teacher will be repeating himself numerous times for various reasons. It's simply the "nature of the beast" - 005faa61, Apr 22, 2011
2
votes

I don't think people believe that there's a magic way to learn a new language. When this ask "What's an easy way to...." they simply want to know the best or most efficient way to conquer a difficult task. For example: Someone washing a floor with a toothbrush may ask "Is there an easier way to do this?", so you hand them a mop, and make their lives a bit easier.

To ask "What's an easy way to...." implies that there is/should be an "easy" way. This, in turn, implies that either a) the person believes that teachers (and textbooks) have entered into a general conspiracy to make life more difficult for the student but that someone out there knows the secret (magic bullet) that will unlock the mysteries of a foreign language. b) that other languages are essentially quite similar to English (or whatever the questioner's language is) and that all that one need is the "magic key" to be able to decode them.

Despite all the advertising hype, if someone actually did have a method for learning a language in three weeks (or whatever), he could become rich overnight (strictly speaking, "in short order" ["overnight" is typical of the exaggeration so often used by advertisers]).

The simple truth is that languages differ in many ways. If one insists in believing that ones own language is "logical" and should be the standard by which all other languages should be measured, then one is doomed to frustration.

All natural languages display a considerable degree of illogicality and (even when they are internally logical/consistent they almost certainly follow a different logic from other languages).

Questions about differences in pronunciation display a similar insensitivity to the real world. Except for postage-stamp sized countries (such as Monaco) any country with more than a million, or so, inhabitants is likely to display differences in pronunciation and idioms. To be unaware of this (especially in the case of English speakers) displays an astonishing lack of sensitivity to language.Differences in pronunciation among regions is the norm not the exception.

The rules of the forum suggest doing a search for previous answers before asking a question. These are not simply rules but, rather, good suggestions. A week does not go by without someone asking "How do I say 'I love you' in Spanish", "How to use 'ser' 'estar'"?, "What's the difference between the imperfect and the preterit?", "I don't understand direct/indirect object pronouns", "What are 'reflexive' verbs?", etc..A search (despite the inadequacies of the search engine) will turn up dozens (perhaps, scores or hundreds) of previous threads dealing with the topic. It is extremely frustrating for the person who has taken the trouble to craft a response to this same question a dozen times, to find the question repeated. Perhaps, some really dedicated pedagogues would simply repeat a previous answer (however many times asked) but many normal people would simply respond "Asked and answered!.(If you want to know, get up off your b*tt and do a bit of research!."

updated Apr 21, 2011
posted by samdie
2
votes

I agree with Felix. I was thinking the same thing while reading Culé's "question".

Perhaps many of us use the term "easy" too often, or it isn't what they really mean to say. There are ways to help us learn things that are difficult to remember, i.e., acronyms to help remember when to use Ser or Estar.

I agree Culé, learning a second language is VERY difficult! When you think about it, it takes a baby/child a long time (years) to learn their FIRST language. Many of us never learn correct grammar for our first language (thanks to an inadequate education). I have also found that this is a hinderance to learning a second language.

updated Apr 21, 2011
posted by Gillygaloo
1
vote

Wow , its getting thick in here .I'm going to flashcards.

updated Apr 21, 2011
posted by heliotropeman
0
votes

arh1 said:

For example, I have heard speakers from certain places regularly leave the endings off of words when they speak. For someone who is learning Spanish, I think this can be very difficult to understand because someone who is not fluent in a language must really focus on every sound that he or she hears in order to understand what is being said.

I have run into to this difficulty while visiting a certain region and it can be frustrating. After memorizing words and phrases for a really long time and then trying to communicate with people who leave the endings or certain sounds out of a word can cause a real dive in one's confidence.

However, I have heard from Spanish speaking friends struggling to learn English that the same thing occurs for them. One Dominican friend can not understand a single thing that is said in the southern U.S. A Chilean friend said that she was taught English by British nuns. In her opinion, people from the U.S. shorten everything and she is never quite sure what we are saying because she doesn't consider it to be "proper" English.

I guess this is just a phenomenon that anyone learning any language will have to face to some degree or another. To be honest, I find it difficult to understand English speaking people from different regions and I'm sure many would be unable to understand me. wink

updated Apr 21, 2011
posted by Nicole-B