Home
Q&A
¡Seamos saludables ahora!

¡Seamos saludables ahora!

0
votes

Supposed to say "Get healthy now!" presumably "Let's get healthy now!".

Sea saludable ahora - I (will) get healthy now (command to me, can you even do this give yourself a command?)

Sé saludable ahora - You (will) get healthy now.

Sea saludable ahora - Usted / He / She (will) get healthy now. (but only usted can receive this as a command)

¡Seamos saludables ahora! We (will) get healthy now. OR (Let's get healthy now)

Seems like a weird command. The command form shares the let's form, doesn't it? So in essence let's IS a command because you being included making it let's changes out of command form and into let's form.

Mira eso - Look at that. (you)

Mire eso - Look at that (usted / he / she) but only usted form can be command, because you can't command a third person.

Miremos eso - Let's look at that. The command is to all of us and therefore no command, just let's.

Only the we form can do let's.

Sigh. Just thinking out loud. I prefer to air my thoughts, lest they be incorrect and go uncorrected. I know this is first grader stuff but I'm just doing a brief review.

Gracias.

1531 views
updated Apr 14, 2011
posted by jeezzle

2 Answers

1
vote

"Sea" - in contexts like this, should be taken more as encouragement than a strict command.

Sea / se bueno: be good

Sea millonario: Be a millionaire!

Sea exitoso: be successful

Sea feliz y admirado: be happy and admired

By contrast:

¡Sea fuerte, no llore! - Be strong, don't cry!

¡Sea valiente, déjese de mariqueras! (not very nice, I know, but people do say things like this) - Be brave and drop the girlie act!

updated Apr 14, 2011
posted by Gekkosan
Thanks, so more for encouragement. Got it. - jeezzle, Apr 14, 2011
1
vote

Languages change rather significantly within 30-70 years, so I cannot predict the future, and especially when these changes are regional.

But I can tell you that in Spain, as today, your suggestions sound rather strange (but not wrong). I would go for something like "Siga/tenga una vida sana" or something like that. But these suggestions change quickly over time.

updated Apr 14, 2011
posted by lazarus1907
Oh - that's funny! Must be a regional thing then. Those expressions are perfectly familiar to me! - Gekkosan, Apr 14, 2011
Thanks, I appreciate your help. - jeezzle, Apr 14, 2011