Home
Q&A
¿ Cómo es la comida? Espero que la disfrutaste?

¿ Cómo es la comida? Espero que la disfrutaste?

1
vote

¿ Cómo es la comida? Espero que la disfrutaste?

How is the food? I hope you enjoyed it?

Please review my sentence construction and correct.

Thank You

6143 views
updated Apr 7, 2011
posted by Polyglot1day
In addition to the other comments, I would use past tense in the first sentence - both languages. If you are asking in general about the food, and no accompanying past experiences, then present tense works - 005faa61, Apr 6, 2011

4 Answers

4
votes

You wrote "la disfrutaste", and since it is indicative, you are telling the other person with this phrase that he/she did enjoy the meal. Saying that you hope that something you declare as a fact happened is weird. This is why we use subjunctive.

updated Apr 7, 2011
posted by lazarus1907
:) - cogumela, Apr 6, 2011
can we use the word 'gustar' here instead of 'disfrutaste'?! - laya_87, Apr 6, 2011
Thank you very much, you advice was extremely useful. - Polyglot1day, Apr 7, 2011
3
votes

If you wanted to write it using the present subjunctive you could say;

¿Cómo fue la comida? Espero que estés disfrutando de la comida

o

or using the past subjunctive you could say:

¿Cómo fue la comida? Espero que hayas disfrutado de la comida

I hope that helps grin

updated Apr 7, 2011
edited by FELIZ77
posted by FELIZ77
buena respuesta - 00494d19, Apr 6, 2011
Thanks Heidi ;-P :) :-) - FELIZ77, Apr 6, 2011
Thanks - Polyglot1day, Apr 7, 2011
2
votes

I think that the sentence is just wrong as worded.

A proper way to ask would be: "¿Cómo fue (estuvo) la comida? Espero que la hayas disfrutado"

updated Apr 7, 2011
edited by 00e657d4
posted by 00e657d4
Thanks so kind :-) - Polyglot1day, Apr 7, 2011
0
votes

¿Cómo estuvo la comida? Espero que la hayas disfutado.

("¿Cómo fue la comida? is a tad...off, in my opinion; it's more akin to asking "¿Cómo es la comida?" which would imply how it is shaped, what's its color, what's the texture; "como estuvo" is the past of "como está" which denotes how it tastes, was it satisfying, enjoyable, not enjoyable, etc.)

updated Apr 7, 2011
posted by 002067fe
Thank you - Polyglot1day, Apr 7, 2011