Home
Q&A
Is that a grammar mistake?

Is that a grammar mistake?

5
votes

alt text

I found this picture on the internet. Was the sign not supposed to say trees falling

1801 views
updated Oct 10, 2011
posted by aganerd
See answers below - it can be regarded as an abreviation for "We are felling trees" - so be careful! - ian-hill, Apr 4, 2011
I agree. - tbrown422, Oct 10, 2011

4 Answers

7
votes

Up here near the Canadian border, lots of tree felling goes on! It's timber country here, and "to fell" is a special verb meaning to cut down. It almost always refers to a tree ("We need to fell that tree before the wind blows it down,") but can also be used in this way: "My little cousin was felled by a stray bullet during a robbery."

updated Oct 10, 2011
posted by Luzbonita
thank you - aganerd, Apr 4, 2011
3
votes

It's the same over here in England. Tree felling is the action of cutting or chopping down a tree.

Tree falling is an indication that the tree is in fact falling or could be that the tree is likely to fall at any moment.

updated Apr 4, 2011
posted by Eddy
helpful thanks - aganerd, Apr 4, 2011
2
votes

I think it is possible to "fell" anything "that can be taken down"; "The contender for the boxing championship was felled in the first round." "The ancient sky-scraper was felled with explosives."

updated Apr 4, 2011
posted by Lector_Constante
Great examples, PR. - Luzbonita, Apr 4, 2011
1
vote

Dictator felling on the grounds of ugliness and barbaric behaviour

alt text

updated Apr 4, 2011
posted by 005faa61
I think they meant failing. - lorenzo9, Apr 4, 2011