Home
Q&A
"El señor al que nada le importaba un comino"

"El señor al que nada le importaba un comino"

7
votes

This is more for beginners and intermediates, you natives and advanced will know this immediately., let the rest of us try this before you answer

I encountered this phrase in a small book I am reading,

This is the title of a chapter

"El señor al que nada le importaba un comino"

The first part of the phrase caused brain failure, the second part was fairly easy.

What say you?

3948 views
updated Apr 5, 2011
edited by --Mariana--
posted by pacofinkler
Hey Paco, one question: the phrases aren't independent of each other, right? :) - cristalino, Apr 3, 2011
no they are a statement, I divided it to be more clear )an error maybe? - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
Check it Chris! - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
You flatter me, Paco! I can barely check to see if my calabaza is on straight most mornings! :o) - cristalino, Apr 3, 2011
There's no comma between "nada" and "le". A comma there changes the entire context of the intended statement (although in that alternate context, it would still be grammatically incorrect for reasons that have nothing to do with the comma). - 002067fe, Apr 3, 2011
I now agree on the comma Tom, but is direct from the chapter title. - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
Really? The chapter is titled "El señor al que nada, le importaba un comino"? Is it maybe a play on words, somehow? What is the book about? - 002067fe, Apr 3, 2011
The little book is popurri a humorous book by Gerardo Mendez 1986 - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
"potpourri" amigo? In case any are unsure... :) - cristalino, Apr 3, 2011
It is a Popurri of many humorous stories on many topics - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
10-4, Paco... popurrí en español, potpourri in English... my bad! :) - cristalino, Apr 3, 2011
y yo falta la tilde arrgh - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
see the answer below - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011

13 Answers

2
votes

I see this is still causing confusion. No wonder, because the title is in fact a devious word play, that fuses two common expressions, and makes fun of the use of double negatives in Spanish.

People usually say: "me importa un comino", to meant that I really don't care much about this. Also it is common to say: "No me importa" or "no me importa nada" - roughly, nothing matters to me.

The problem is rather similar to the confusion and conflict in English between those who say "I could care less" and "I couldn't care less". By and large, anyone who uses either expression means "I don't care". But technically speaking, "I could care less" means that I do care at least a little bit.

So when you're presented with "El hombre al que nada le importa un comino" you have a similar problem with how to interpret: "The man who couldn't care less about nothing".

...

Wait - so does he care, or doesn't he? It's a double negative, so logically he cares about everything, right?

El hombre al que nada (the man to whom nothing) - le importa un comino (hardly matters at all). So he must be concerned about everything, he must care very much about every little thing.

updated Apr 5, 2011
posted by Gekkosan
Exacto Gekkosan,I knew you knew it !! - pacofinkler, Apr 4, 2011
It´s easy ;It´s like mathematical language: - + - =¿? - lukaaxx, Apr 4, 2011
For you natives yes! that one nearly drove me to drink in the middle of the day! - pacofinkler, Apr 4, 2011
As I said - it is confusing. I believe it would fool many natives, too, if they don't stop to think about it, or read it out of context. - Gekkosan, Apr 4, 2011
Thank you gekkosan! - pacofinkler, Apr 5, 2011
Thank Gekko for clearing this up. So I wasn´t far off . but wouldn´t the double negative be correct in Spanish.? - BellaMargarita, Apr 5, 2011
3
votes

Okay the answer is, And by the way I had to call a native speaker to help me with it.

"El señor al que nada le importaba un comino"

"The man to whom no detail was too small"

"the man to whom" was what made me crazy

updated Apr 4, 2011
posted by pacofinkler
2
votes

"The man to whom no detail was too small"?

What Spanish-speaking country accepts that meaning for ""El señor al que nada le importaba un comino" ?

It's not at all what I have always heard it used for.

updated Apr 4, 2011
posted by 002067fe
Okay, Tom, you're keeping us in suspense - what have you heard it used for? - pesta, Apr 4, 2011
One that treats double negatives the way they do in English. - lorenzo9, Apr 4, 2011
2
votes

Wait this is not at all trivial. As Tom indicated, the sentence is very different if it has a comma and if it doesn't. Which one is it, exactly?

Without the comma, is a fairly simply, straightforward sentence. With the comma, it becomes a more difficult-to-explain word play.

updated Apr 4, 2011
posted by Gekkosan
Gekkosan It is a chapter title written on two lines, to me it would not have a comma.I wish i could be more positive on this. - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
In that case it's "El señor al que nada le importaba un comino". Straigthforward enough then. - Gekkosan, Apr 3, 2011
It is the first part of the statment that made me crazy. - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
I knew you knew! - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
2
votes

The man who hated cumin in his food?? tongue wink

updated Apr 4, 2011
posted by 002067fe
Jejejeje too funny tom! - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
The first part of the phrase drove me nuts, the second part was easy. - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
:-) - 002067fe, Apr 3, 2011
Answer below Tom - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
2
votes

Hmm, this does seem kind of hard. I have a few ideas, but I'm not really sure. The man to whom nothing mattered? The man who cared about nothing? The man who didn't care? Well, I guess those are all just rewordings of what I think it might mean, but I thought maybe one of them would sound better than the others.

updated Apr 3, 2011
posted by Becky32
It frustrated me too until I had a native speaker intervene.try again ,when you discover it you will laugh. - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
Wow, I have no more ideas for now, but I'm definitely going to keep watching this thread. I'm so curious now! :P - Becky32, Apr 3, 2011
Paciencia Becky! - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
see the answer below becky - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
1
vote

The man who did not care could less about anything.

updated Apr 5, 2011
posted by BellaMargarita
Huh? %-P - Gekkosan, Apr 4, 2011
I am a native and I have to hold my tongue but ...It,easy.It´s like mathematical language: - + - = ? - lukaaxx, Apr 4, 2011
Funny I got a vote and confusion ? After looking at this I am it was not the smoothest - BellaMargarita, Apr 5, 2011
Bella margaret, if you tried you got a vote! :-) - pacofinkler, Apr 5, 2011
1
vote

Hello all

This little book "popurrí was published in México in 1986. The phrase is one of the chapter titles. The chapter has to do with a man to whom no tiny detail is too small.

I could not manage the meaning of the first part of the statement.I live in the north of mexico and a friend of mine,a native speaker, knew it immediatly.

updated Apr 5, 2011
posted by pacofinkler
1
vote

¿Un señor que importaba cominos de la India?

link text

updated Apr 4, 2011
posted by lukaaxx
je,je ¿que chiste más malo eh? - lukaaxx, Apr 4, 2011
¿Puedes darnos la traducción al inglés? - BellaMargarita, Apr 4, 2011
It was hard for me in the first part of the phrase."the man to whom nothing" - pacofinkler, Apr 4, 2011
Es una broma que he hecho bellamargar,El comino es una especia que en España se usa bastante y hace los platos mas digestivos.http://www.vegetariantimes.com/media/originals/3783-VT07_071707-Cumin.jpg - lukaaxx, Apr 4, 2011
www.vegetariantimes.com/media/originals/3783-VT07_071707-Cumin.jpg - lukaaxx, Apr 4, 2011
1
vote

The man that nothing mattered to--he didn't give a darn

updated Apr 3, 2011
posted by sanlee
Oh, I missed the answer. No kidding - sanlee, Apr 3, 2011
i could not get the first part without help Sandy - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
1
vote

It looks like "The man who didn't give a **** about anything."

updated Apr 3, 2011
posted by lorenzo9
No lorenzo , I'l post it in a bit, its so easy and yet it cleaned my clock - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
here it is. - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
Yeah Lorenzo... I equated "comino" with "bledo" and figured nothing mattered to this dude! - cristalino, Apr 3, 2011
1
vote

The first part seems to be saying: The man (or gentleman, sir) to whom nothing.... or for whom nothing... does that come close to your rendering? grin

updated Apr 3, 2011
posted by cristalino
That would be telling wait a bit! - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
Ah, see I was attempting translation with just the first "clause"... now it's become a whole sentence, right? - cristalino, Apr 3, 2011
Uh Huh! - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
see the answer below Chris - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011
1
vote

So.... what is the answer??!! rolleyes

updated Apr 3, 2011
posted by Gillygaloo
C'mon Ten paciencia ! - pacofinkler, Apr 3, 2011