Home
Q&A
I'm considering taking the plunge..

I'm considering taking the plunge..

2
votes

and buying Rosetta Stone. Anyone think I'm making the wrong choice?

2843 views
updated Apr 1, 2011
edited by 00494d19
posted by claylavl
I cannot recommend it having used it. - pacofinkler, Mar 29, 2011
You've used it? - claylavl, Mar 29, 2011
I have I should post an answer really. - pacofinkler, Mar 29, 2011
What problems did you have with Rosetta Stone? - claylavl, Mar 29, 2011
See my answer - pacofinkler, Mar 29, 2011
Ha! I thought you had decided to get married! I was all set to congratulate you! :) - mountaingirl123, Mar 30, 2011
It's a good program, I would say it's worth about 50 euro per level, not 300. - rabbitwho, Mar 30, 2011

13 Answers

2
votes

I would recommend you do a 'search' on this site and read up on all the comments others have proffered on that very subject... I think you will find plenty or at least a good amount, that will show a negative consensus on that product.... I hope that helps some! cheese

updated Mar 30, 2011
posted by cristalino
A long time ago I inquired about it and got mixed reviews. My main downfall is I don't speak Spanish enough. Rosetta Stone will enable me to at least speak it more. - claylavl, Mar 29, 2011
As with any learning program, I suppose the amount of time & effort you put into it will ultimately determine its "worth"... perhaps widening your search to the other sites, say like Consumer Reports or a similar entity :) - cristalino, Mar 29, 2011
That's true. Time and effort. - claylavl, Mar 30, 2011
2
votes

Go to Google and type in "Free Spanish lessons." Most aren't too good, and some are fantastic (like this one). Because we all have different learning abilities and knowledge levels, there is no one website that is the best for everybody.

updated Mar 30, 2011
posted by Vince53
Good point Although very few if any could match this one for free facilities and friendly community spirit :) - FELIZ77, Mar 30, 2011
Spanishdict is my favorite of all Spanish sites. I'm surprised it's still free! - claylavl, Mar 30, 2011
2
votes

I used Rosetta Stone Level I for Latin. I found it hugely expensive and not nearly as good as this site is for Spanish. Between this site, Bueno Entonces and Conjugation Nation on my iPhone, all of which combined are cheaper than level I Rosetta Stone, I've got Spanish covered.

updated Mar 30, 2011
posted by ocbizlaw
thanks. I'll look into the programs you listed. - claylavl, Mar 29, 2011
1
vote

All right ,I did not really want to post regarding this. there are many treads on this already. I had a 'hot version" of rosetta stone in spanish, it does teach you many good basics no fault there at all, What it does not teach is is how to understand or respond to a question you might ask a spanish speaker.

For example ¿donde está el bano?

Está en al fin del pasillo en la derecha, pero está fuera de servicio en este momento.

Now what will you do?

updated Apr 1, 2011
edited by pacofinkler
posted by pacofinkler
Please correct my spanish in this - pacofinkler, Mar 29, 2011
hmm..i see what you mean. - claylavl, Mar 29, 2011
Paco, you pee in your pants, or at least I might! :o) How about "Está en la orilla del pasillo, a mano derecha...?" - cristalino, Mar 29, 2011
I do not want to negate it as a way to get your basics, - pacofinkler, Mar 29, 2011
And el baño es averiado... but you are so RIGHT... what do you say next?? :o) - cristalino, Mar 29, 2011
what other choices are available? - claylavl, Mar 29, 2011
If it were me it would be al final de pasillo a la derecha orilla is new to me - pacofinkler, Mar 29, 2011
Remember i´m a gringo learning Chris - pacofinkler, Mar 29, 2011
I'm probably just as 'gringo' as you, my friend... some phrases and concepts just come to me quicker, especially if one has to find a bathroom in a hurry! :) - cristalino, Mar 29, 2011
Jejeje :-) - pacofinkler, Mar 29, 2011
¡Abrase la ventana pronto! - lorenzo9, Apr 1, 2011
1
vote

I am amused by 'reviews' of Rosetta Stone from people who have pirated the software. For the person that was disappointed that RS didn't teach you how to greet people, start at level 1, unit 1. You will have said Hola, Cómo estás and Adiós so many times you will throw up. Paco, from Level 4, you will find the question ¿Dónde está el baño? and the answer is based on previously learned material, Sigue derecho....es la segunda puerta a la derecha. There is an entire unit devoted to giving and receiving directions in minute detail, covering some of the very points you deride. I've gone through the entire 5 levels of RS Latin American Spanish, and it worked for me. I also use other methods of learning. In less than 3 years I can converse in Spanish, and I owe most of my vocabulary and pronunciation skills to RS.

updated Apr 1, 2011
posted by Jack-OBrien
There is hope after all. I wasn't going to buy it with all the reviews I got. I've heard the US Military uses RS to train soldiers for foreign relations. - claylavl, Apr 1, 2011
my main fault is not speaking spanish enough. RS will engange me to speak. - claylavl, Apr 1, 2011
1
vote

Here is what you need to keep in mind about Rosetta Stone, it teaches objects very well. For example, dog, cat, mouse, ball, etc. are easy to learn and remember. I have been using Rosetta Stone for two years and the hardest part is verbs and words like que and se whose meanings may not seem apparent at first.

It is recommended by the Customer Support at Rosetta Stone that you use the program with another curriculum. I had some issues with it last year, but now they are all resolved. I must say though, it takes a little bit of decoding to understand verbs and relationships between people and objects.

updated Apr 1, 2011
posted by wazupwiop
1
vote

I really don't like to double post on a thread, but this has got me going.

Here, and only here,"hasta donde yo se" (as far as I know) can you post what may seem to be silly questions on points of language use, and get good solid usable answers, and links to answers. The lessons are good, the flashcards and reference materials as well. And we get to enjoy the forum. try it for a while, you may come to enjoy it as the rest of us do.

And its free.

updated Mar 31, 2011
posted by pacofinkler
Spanishdict is amazing. I love this site. - claylavl, Mar 31, 2011
1
vote

I torrented it. It's not bad. I enjoy it, but I have also never taken a Spanish lesson before. Though, I would have liked it better if it had started out with Greetings and such..Seeing as I can talk all I want about how 'the boy and the man eat sandwiches' or how 'three women are wearing pants and one woman is wearing a skirt' but I can't answer what my name is.....oh my. I leave for Mexico in a month and I can't even tell them were I'm from or my name..That's my only downfall with it so far. But that's only the first lesson in level 1... if anything, I'd say torrent it. But if you look at a Spanish lesson in a University or College..it's approx $200 (same price as Rosette Stone) so, it's up to you. I hope that helped. Just ask if you have any further questions. smile

-Nessa

updated Mar 30, 2011
posted by neska05
I took a Spanish class last semester. It didn't do a lot for me. - claylavl, Mar 30, 2011
1
vote

I liked;

Take Off In Spanish

From Oxford University Press

It was a lot of fun.

-Scott

updated Mar 30, 2011
posted by teasip
1
vote

You could get the free demo disk. I got it and was not impressed with it at all but maybe you would like it.

updated Mar 30, 2011
posted by Ron_Austin
I did the demo online. It was so-so. - claylavl, Mar 30, 2011
1
vote

I would also recommend reading the reviews on amazon.com. I read them a while back and the reviews were mixed. The general consensus seemed to be that you were paying a lot for marketing and advertising and much higher cost didn't necessarily mean the product was any better than others on the market.

updated Mar 29, 2011
posted by fatchocobo
Are there discs that are comparable but cheaper? - claylavl, Mar 29, 2011
There are many. I would start with the lessons here on this website that are free. - fatchocobo, Mar 29, 2011
Why do you think the lessons in Rosetta Stone would be any better than the lessons anywhere else? - fatchocobo, Mar 29, 2011
I bought Rocket Spanish which is much cheaper, but I find myself at this site more than at the Rocket Spanish. They do have downloadable MP3 lessons though - Ron_Austin, Mar 29, 2011
0
votes

Thanks Vince53. I'll do that.

updated Mar 29, 2011
posted by claylavl
0
votes

what other choices are available?

updated Mar 29, 2011
posted by claylavl
I wonder if eBay or Amazon (like Fat mentioned) might have it cheaper or maybe Paco will sell you his "hot" copy! je je - cristalino, Mar 29, 2011