Home
Q&A
Adjective Clauses

Adjective Clauses

1
vote

Is it correct to say: ..............

  1. I often think about the moment when my son died
  2. They said me, my son was flying taking a Instruction course, when his plane down

I'm trying to use in the first sentence identifying clause, and in the second sentence Nonidentifying clause

Thanks

3668 views
updated Mar 15, 2011
posted by maylegoas
It should be "the told me". Everything else is correct. - Leatha, Mar 15, 2011
He told me, my son was flying..........is it OK? - maylegoas, Mar 15, 2011

4 Answers

1
vote

They TOLD me, my son was taking a flying Instruction course, when his plane down.

This can not be a non defining relative clause (NDRC) because when you remove the part between the commas you do not have a good sentence.

DRC Politicians who tell lies are awful. = only politicians who tell lies are awful.

NDRC Politicians, who tell lies, are awful. = all politician are awful.

The "who tell lies" is just extra information and can be removed. = Politicians are awful.

Much of the time when a DRC is removed the sentence becomes meaningless.

updated Mar 15, 2011
edited by ian-hill
posted by ian-hill
ok ian-hill I´m going to corret my sentence, because I need that it is as nonidentifying clause, please could you cheak it? thanks - maylegoas, Mar 15, 2011
Ok will do when you change it or post another attempt. - ian-hill, Mar 15, 2011
0
votes

They told me my son was flying, taking an instruction course, when his plane down.

Now you have a NDRC which can be removed without the sentence becoming meaningless.

updated Mar 15, 2011
edited by ian-hill
posted by ian-hill
0
votes

They told me my son was having a flying lesson when his plane went down.

updated Mar 15, 2011
posted by Sabor
Sabor, is it nonidentifying clause? - maylegoas, Mar 15, 2011
0
votes

I often think about the moment when my son died. = Correct

They said me, my son was flying taking a Instruction course, when his plane down. = Incorrect

They told me that my son was taking a flying instruction course when his plane when down. = Correct

updated Mar 15, 2011
posted by --Mariana--
thanks Mariana, but I know that Nonidentifying Clause is between comas - maylegoas, Mar 15, 2011