Adjective Clauses
Is it correct to say: ..............
- I often think about the moment when my son died
- They said me, my son was flying taking a Instruction course, when his plane down
I'm trying to use in the first sentence identifying clause, and in the second sentence Nonidentifying clause
Thanks
4 Answers
They TOLD me, my son was taking a flying Instruction course, when his plane down.
This can not be a non defining relative clause (NDRC) because when you remove the part between the commas you do not have a good sentence.
DRC Politicians who tell lies are awful. = only politicians who tell lies are awful.
NDRC Politicians, who tell lies, are awful. = all politician are awful.
The "who tell lies" is just extra information and can be removed. = Politicians are awful.
Much of the time when a DRC is removed the sentence becomes meaningless.
They told me my son was flying, taking an instruction course, when his plane down.
Now you have a NDRC which can be removed without the sentence becoming meaningless.
They told me my son was having a flying lesson when his plane went down.