Home
Q&A
Why "siempre es" and why the use of "lo"?

Why "siempre es" and why the use of "lo"?

1
vote

Siempre es una buena idea esperar lo inesperado.

In the above sentence I wasn't sure why Izanoni1 suggested using "Siempre es" and why he used esperar lo inesperado. Here is a link to my post to get more context. You are looking for the bears that demolished a tent! Link to my answer: English Word of the Day: Expect

My reasoning and sources:

In the SD dictionary under siempre: 2. always (en cualquier caso)

•siempre es mejor estar preparado -> it's always better to be prepared

1 - It is ---> It = subject, is = verb? And in Spanish sentences the subject precedes the verb?

2 - In the above definition is another example of "It is always...

As far as "esperar lo" goes I'm not at all sure why lo is used.

It is always a good idea to expect the unexpected.

it is a good idea to expect what ---> the unexpected

so "the unexpected" is a direct object?

The direct object concept is a piece of this but I'm missing some more info or not applying a rule? Something is amiss in my thinking! smile

1531 views
updated Mar 7, 2011
posted by bandit51jd
I think I understand. In Spanish it's very natural to use "siempre es" for "It is always" (most of the time)? - bandit51jd, Mar 3, 2011
And when talking about good, it goes before the noun rather than after; because it's Spanish and natural? Ex: bueno hijo, or buena abuela? - bandit51jd, Mar 3, 2011
When there is a masculine adjective being used as a noun; the use of the nuetral article "lo" is used; it expresses an abstract idea or places emphasis on the m. adj. being used like a noun? - bandit51jd, Mar 3, 2011

2 Answers

2
votes

Hi bandit!

The original sentence was :

Es siempre una idea buena esperar el inesperado.

The reasons for the corrections about

Es siempre --> siempre es, and

idea buena --> buena idea

are not grammatical, Spanish is flexible in this point, but the way in which Iza corrected it (perfect in my opinion) is the way how the vast majority of times this words are said.

Siempre is not the subject of the sentence, the subject of the sentence is "esperar lo inesperado" and, as you can see, in Spanish the subject is not always placed before the verb.

Esperar lo inesperado es siempre una buena idea.

Eso es siempre una buena idea

about the other correction:

el inesperado --> lo inesperado

The use of "lo", the neutral definite article, is mandatory here. This happens each time you want to use a masculine adjective like a noun:

Lo malo, lo rojo, lo grande, lo inesperado...

Lo inesperado is not a direct object, the direct object is "una buena idea"

Esperar lo inesperado siempre "lo" es ( una buena idea)

updated Mar 7, 2011
edited by cogumela
posted by cogumela
1
vote

It's always better to expect the unexpected. This is almost a one-to-one between English and Spanish.

Siempre es mejor esperar lo inesperado. Siempre should go before the verb es to convey the same meaning as English. If you change the place of siempre you'll end up with different meanings.

Es mejor siempre esperar lo inesperado. It's better to always wait (I know, we are not supposed to split infinitives in English. I am doing it here to make a point)

Es mejor esperar lo inesperado siempre (same meaning as the first sentence).

Lo is the neutral article and it's perfect here to express something uncertain. But you can also say Siempre es mejor esperar la correspondencia, el café recién colado, etc.

updated Mar 3, 2011
edited by gone
posted by gone
I slighly disagree with: "lo" is perfect to express something uncertain, usar :) - cogumela, Mar 3, 2011
I also think that "siempre" can be placed everywhere in this sentence. - cogumela, Mar 3, 2011
...excepting between the words "buena idea" and "lo inesperado" - cogumela, Mar 3, 2011
Gracias, I have not really used the neutral article before. Thank goodness there is only one, lo! - bandit51jd, Mar 3, 2011