Home
Q&A
ser and estar question

ser and estar question

1
vote

I know that "Ella es viuda (she is a widow)" is correct. But my Spanish teacher had told me that Ella está viuda is also correct.

I am quite confused. Could someone please explain this. Any help would be appreciated.

2367 views
updated Mar 8, 2011
posted by hanran
Hanran: could you please enable downloads on WizIQ of the transcripts. Thanks. - DilKen, Mar 8, 2011

3 Answers

4
votes

ella está viuda=she is widowed. (adjective)

ella es viuda=she is a widow (noun)

updated Feb 23, 2011
posted by 0074b507
Are there exceptions to this rule? - Sabor, Feb 23, 2011
muchas gracias, qfreed - hanran, Feb 23, 2011
0
votes

hi friend,

as our friend, gfreed, noted, it is important to see if the word is used as an adjective or as a noun. you know, "estar" can not be used with noun. so the viuda after "ser"=es, is a noun.

updated Feb 23, 2011
posted by je2010
0
votes

"ella está viuda" is used only if it is something recent, i think

updated Feb 22, 2011
posted by elotroleonardo