Home
Q&A
how do you tell if a sentence is subjuctive or indicative

how do you tell if a sentence is subjuctive or indicative

3
votes

How do you tell if a sentence is subjuctive or indicative? Example: what would this sentence be, El padre de Ixta no quiere que su hija (casarse) ___________ con un principe chichimeca. grin Thanks!

3523 views
updated Feb 22, 2011
posted by LMSROCKS24
SubjuNctive - Eddy, Feb 22, 2011

5 Answers

2
votes

It's subjunctive, as it's a wish of her father. It's worth following the link in the other post for a clear explanation. El padre de Ixta no quiere que su hija se case con un principe chichimeca.

updated Feb 22, 2011
posted by Encalada
Yes I agree Two subjects are present: the father and the girl joined by the relative pronoun que - FELIZ77, Feb 22, 2011
Two clauses with two different verbs in each the indicative and the subjucntive following - FELIZ77, Feb 22, 2011
1
vote

It is subjuctive because if you say se casa it sounds like you are saying The father doesn't want her daughter is marrying ... but you want to say ... to marry... **; the indicative is just that: indicative of what is going on, but there is no action taking place and and it is not definite that an action will take place, so that's why there's a **MOOD called the subjunctive that needs to be used. It is easier to understand this that to memorize rules. I'm not a native speaker but this is what it sounds like in the other languages I know (none of latin roots,that's why I'm not sure) so please correct me if I'm wrong. grin

updated Feb 22, 2011
posted by preny
1
vote

This thing of categorizing sentences can be a bit confusing, which is why I also think you should follow Kevin's link. It's confusing because the first part of the sentence is indicative El padre de Ixta no quiere and the second part is subjunctive que su hija se case con un principe chichimeca.

What tells indicitive or subjunctive is the verb conjugation.

updated Feb 22, 2011
posted by 005faa61
1
vote

Welcome to the forum. The subjunctive vs. indicative is one of the more complex topics in Spanish. The lesson here is a good start.

updated Feb 22, 2011
posted by KevinB
0
votes

se case

updated Feb 22, 2011
posted by Rey_Mysterio