Home
Q&A
Ir is different from irse (with pictures)

Ir is different from irse (with pictures)

15
votes

alt text

2915 views
updated Nov 25, 2011
edited by Seb79
posted by lazarus1907
Jajaja! Súper :) - cogumela, Jan 13, 2011
great - Izanoni1, Jan 13, 2011
Me divierten mucho Mortadelo y Filemón... pero, Lazarus, no entiendo tu título... :-) - Gekkosan, Jan 13, 2011
I didn't know what you meant by your title..... - Seb79, Jan 13, 2011
Now I get it ! Thank you so much , the Penney has dropped at last. - ray76, Nov 25, 2011

7 Answers

5
votes

ir = to go someplace in particular
irse = to go somewhere other than here, leave, get out

Edit - Examples:

Voy a la tienda = I am going to the store
Fuimos por avión = We went by airplane

Mis padres se fueron ayer = My parents left yesterday
¡Vete! = Go! (Get out!)

updated Mar 24, 2011
edited by KevinB
posted by KevinB
ir a, irse de? - Stadt, Jan 13, 2011
It's more the general sense of the words. Either could be followed by several different words, depending on the circumstance. - KevinB, Jan 13, 2011
Basically ir emphasizes the destination or the means, irse emphasizes the act of leaving. - KevinB, Jan 13, 2011
Thanks - Stadt, Jan 13, 2011
4
votes

Hmm ... obviously I'm a bit slow tonight. Let me see if I've understood this properly.

Sñr Super says "... tiene que ir ahora mismo". The other bloke (being an idiot) leaves without knowing where he should go because Sñr S. didn't say "... tiene que irse

Did I get the joke?

updated Nov 25, 2011
posted by patch
That's it. - KevinB, Jan 13, 2011
2
votes

I guess I should have clarified what I mean by my title.

Imagine you are with a friend of yours in a party, and all of a sudden, he says:

I'm going!

That makes perfect sense in English, but not in Spanish if you say "Voy", because it is a verb that focuses on the destination above all. A verb whose only point is to indicate a destination makes no sense without one, which is what the comic is using as a joke: Mortadelo "goes" (se va) without hearing the destination, and the "súper" wonders how can he be so silly as to "ir" without knowing where.

The "súper" wanted him to "ir [a un sitio]", and he "se fue" instead.

I don't know whether I'm making any sense.

updated Nov 25, 2011
posted by lazarus1907
Makes sense to me. I thought the comic was excellent. Thanks. - 0074b507, Jan 14, 2011
I understood, but I already knew the difference. - pesta, Jan 14, 2011
I thought it was very funny too, Lazarus:) I have only just seen this page via a link posted by Sonrisa :) - FELIZ77, Nov 25, 2011
2
votes

The comic explains it very well, but if you have trouble remembering the difference, try this: Irse = Largarse

updated Jan 14, 2011
posted by 005faa61
0
votes

It is simple. "Ir" is to go and "Irse" is to leave.

updated Jan 14, 2011
posted by Hungerford
0
votes

Well, the comic + the discussion is a big help. Really clears it up for me.

updated Jan 14, 2011
posted by webdunce
0
votes

irse is go to and ir i go

updated Jan 13, 2011
posted by emmankyle
Not quite. - KevinB, Jan 13, 2011