Home
Q&A
feliz navidad not navidad feliz???

feliz navidad not navidad feliz???

1
vote

Just a random thought i've just had and i can't find a answer for!. If happy birthday is cumpleaños feliz then why isn't happy xmas navidad feliz???

Thanks guys

(Sorry for the bad grammer)

4911 views
updated Dec 21, 2010
edited by jadagod
posted by jadagod
Just to remind you Jada - we have people learning English on this site too so correct English with capital letters etc is encouraged! - margaretbl, Dec 21, 2010
Please, use correct spelling and punctuation as this is a learning site. You can edit your post yourself. Thanks and welcome to SD! - Gocika, Dec 21, 2010

4 Answers

0
votes

Yes and no. If you just say 'Happy birthday' or 'I wish you a happy birthday', then it is 'feliz cumpleaños'. However, the song has the inverse order: 'Cumpleaños feliz'. It's as if it were implied that birthdays (and Christmas too) have to be happy, which is why the adjective (feliz) is in front, to tone it down.

In the song, 'cumpleaños feliz', the adjective is behind, so the meaning comes out stronger than in 'feliz cumpleaños', but it's not used much outside that song.

updated Dec 21, 2010
edited by bill1111
posted by bill1111
2
votes

Happy birthday is felíz cumpleaños and not cumpleaños felíz.

updated Dec 21, 2010
edited by kenwilliams
posted by kenwilliams
Exactly :) - FELIZ77, Dec 21, 2010
Oops! Sorry i had just watched a video on youtube and they were sining cumpleanos feliz?!?! - jadagod, Dec 21, 2010
0
votes

Actually, you say "Feliz cumpleaños" and "Feliz Navidad", but "feliz cumpleaños" cannot be sung as easily as "cumpleaños feliz", hehe.

updated Dec 21, 2010
posted by lazarus1907
0
votes

I understand where they are coming from. Doesn't the adjective come after the noun. Navidad then Feliz? Or is this an exception to the rule? question

updated Dec 21, 2010
posted by matzaball64565