Home
Q&A
Excitada...... bad usage in this book

Excitada...... bad usage in this book

0
votes

This book just used excitada to describe how some people were whispering excitedly. So I went to Amazon to read some reviews of it and many say it is full of bad translations and is a badly translated book. (Harry Potter). In my mind excitada means "sexually excited" like "worked up, and aroused" and to hear some people discussing something in a way that was "excitada" strikes me a sexual connotation. This book wanted to use it as excited which I think of as emocionada. What do you think? I remember an argument where a girl wanted to say she was excited to see her son, and used excitada and everyone said no to her as saying it was too sexual sounding.

4417 views
updated Dec 19, 2010
edited by jeezzle
posted by jeezzle
"everyone jumped on her" given the context that you want to stress there may be better ways to say this. - samdie, Dec 19, 2010
lol ok that made me laugh. ;) - jeezzle, Dec 19, 2010

2 Answers

2
votes

Jeezzle, you are absolutely right about excitado/a. The word has leaked into Spanish as synonym for emocionado/a. The same happens with having sex as ´tener sexo. instead of ´tener relaciones sexuales´.

However, excitar as verb can be used as causing an emotion or feeling. Que ella diga que está excitada excita mi fantasía.

Also, to make nervous: La niña se excita con las visitas.

Also, to cause anger, or joy. Juan se excita con la falta de puntualidad de sus empleados. rolleyes

It´s the adjective what has this disturbing sexual connotation. (maybe becasue it´s close to a copulative verb tongue rolleye )

-

(All examples where taken or modified form D R A E )


And yes, some of Harry Potter´s versions are very poorly translated, although I could not read more than 10 pages.

updated Mar 6, 2012
edited by mediterrunio
posted by mediterrunio
2
votes

All I know is that I am so glad I read a forum post about the same topic before I sent an email to my boyfriend earlier this year. I wanted to tell him I was excited to see him. Thank the SpanishDict gods for saving me from telling him that I was REALLY "excited" to see him. wink

updated Mar 9, 2012
posted by mapletw