Home
Q&A
Question about ser/estar

Question about ser/estar

3
votes

Hola,

Is it possible to say "El presidente es malo"? In my grammar book there's an exercise where you have to make all possible sentences using the words from various columns (it's a ser/estar exercise) and the answers list "El presidente está malo" but not the same with "ser". I would have thought the "ser" version was possible too, but just wanted to check.

Any help much appreciated, Rangi

alt text

1877 views
updated Dec 18, 2010
posted by Rangi

4 Answers

3
votes

Hi Rangi, it's possible but it doesn't mean the same thing as the other.

El presidente está malo. (He could be sick or he's not feeling well.)

El presidente es malo. (This is about his personality.)

Why don't you have a look at the learning section of this website? wink

1.11 - Ser vs. Estar

updated Dec 18, 2010
edited by culé
posted by culé
4
votes

Hi, Ran. Great question.

I would say that:

1) El presidente está malo = the president feels poorly (he's ill)

2) El presidente es malo = the president is a bad guy (his personality)

updated Dec 18, 2010
posted by --Mariana--
1
vote

Muchas gracias guys, thanks very much for the help! ¡Feliz navidad! Rangi

updated Dec 18, 2010
posted by Rangi
1
vote

Indeed. In fact, if you check out any online version of a Spanish newspaper with a right-wing bias, you'll probably find not just one, but multiple instances of that 'sentence' in relation to our own, socialist president wink

By the way, 'El presidente es malo' can mean both that he is a bad person, or that he's a bad president. I was of course referring to the latter.

updated Dec 18, 2010
edited by bill1111
posted by bill1111