Home
Q&A
¿ A qué hora se almuerzan entonces?

¿ A qué hora se almuerzan entonces?

1
vote

In my spanish book, there´s one sentence?¿ A qué hora se almuerzan entonces? I don't know why it's not ¿ A qué hora almuerzan entonces? It's not prnl. it's not like levantarse,vestirse, why it needs se too?? i'm confused. i asked the teacher, and she is Chinese girl, she doesn't know it either. :(

I think i'd better write the whole texto. -Tomas, ¿Tenéis en España un horario igual que aquí? -No,bastante diferente. -¿Cuál es la diferencia? -Nos levantamos tarde, porque no nos acostamos tan temprano como aquí. -¿A qué hora se levantan tus padres, por ejemplo? -A las ocho. Después de vestirse y aseaarse, toman el desayuno. Luego van al trabajo. -Deben comenzar a trabajar las nueve. -Si,o a las nueve y media. -¡Es muy tarde! ¿ A qué hora se almuerzan entonces? -En España decimos "comida". Comemos entre las dos y las tres. -Entonces los españoles debéis cenar a las ocho de la tarde. -¡Qué va! Cenamos a las nueve , nueve y media , e incluso a las diez de la noche.

This is the whole texto.

4062 views
updated Dec 11, 2010
edited by zhmelissa
posted by zhmelissa
Wow...your teacher doesn't know? Talk about the blind leading the blind! - malcriada, Dec 11, 2010

6 Answers

3
votes

Check who wrote the book. If it is not written by a native speaker with a proper education, I'd dismiss it as a typo or a gross mistake, because as far as I know, you don't say "almorzarse" (but you say "desayunarse). None of my dictionaries (not even some as specific as only for uses in Mexico) have that verb as a pronominal, by the way.

Having said that, however, it is possible to say something similar, but in singular only:

¿A qué hora se almuerza entonces? = What time does someone have lunch then?

This usage is impersonal intransitive, because the sentence doesn't even have a subject.

updated Dec 11, 2010
edited by lazarus1907
posted by lazarus1907
I understand the impersonal "se" but I've never seen "desayunarse!" I learn something new every day! - --Mariana--, Dec 11, 2010
"Desayunarse" is slowly disappearing everyday. You may never even hear it. - lazarus1907, Dec 11, 2010
Whew...Okay, thanks! I thought I was really missing something here! - --Mariana--, Dec 11, 2010
2
votes

As far as I know, "se" is often inserted before a verb when the subject cannot really be specified. So in this case the person who asks the question does not refer to a specific group of people but asks rather generally for the hour at which people usually have lunch.

In English this might be phrased as "At what hour does one have lunch around here, then?". If the speaker were referring to a specific group of people, say María y Ramón, he would probably phrase the question without "se".

Disclaimer: I'm neither a native speaker of English ni un hablante nativo de Español, so I might be all wrong here grin

updated Dec 11, 2010
posted by RobertoLeones
1
vote

desayunar.

  1. intr. Tomar el desayuno. U. t. c. tr. y c. prnl. [Úsese también como pronominal]

Real Academia Española © Todos los derechos reservados

updated Dec 12, 2010
posted by lazarus1907
0
votes

I do not know if almorzarse exists or not.

updated Dec 11, 2010
posted by zhmelissa
0
votes

Lazarus said:

but you say "desayunarse

Really??

So, it's "Me desayuné a las 8 de la mañana" instead of "Desayuné a las...."

updated Dec 11, 2010
posted by --Mariana--
Thank you for the answer above, Lazarus. - --Mariana--, Dec 11, 2010
0
votes

Could it be "at what hour does it have lunch then?". Are there questions before or after this question on the same subject or article? Normally that should give you a hint as to what they are talking about. Hope this helps rather than hinders smile

updated Dec 11, 2010
posted by AeryFaery