Home
Q&A
How would you say that something is based off of something else?

How would you say that something is based off of something else?

3
votes

For example, I'm trying to say something along the lines of, "The musical is based off of a book."

16131 views
updated Dec 6, 2010
posted by DaynaMarie

4 Answers

5
votes

I would say based on a book, and then I would translate it as :

El musical Drácula está basado en una novela del siglo XIX,

or El musical se basa en una novela.

updated Dec 6, 2010
posted by mediterrunio
Odd, but our dictionary doesn't list (to) base as a verb. Basar is there fortunately. - 0074b507, Dec 5, 2010
2
votes

From the articles that I looked at for
Based off [of] vs based on most say that based off [of] is incorrect or substandard English.

I could be way off base on this tongue rolleye, but from a logical standpoint, I would think it to be obvious that the correct preposition would be "on," especially considering the semantic meaning of the word/expression. That is to say that if a musical is based on another story, it implies that the newer work has been "built" upon the earlier work (i.e. the earlier work is the base or foundation upon which the newer work is built or rests).

Of course language being what it is, it does not surprise me much when I hear the "based off of..." (colloquial?) version thrown around.

That makes me wonder...does anyone ever says that this country was founded off of the principles of Democracy

updated Dec 6, 2010
edited by Izanoni1
posted by Izanoni1
Great answer Izanoni :) based on is correct English based off /based off of sounds terrible and would not be considered good English - FELIZ77, Dec 6, 2010
no, nobody says that anymore :-D - mediterrunio, Dec 6, 2010
1
vote

Based on a book. link text

Jonathan Livingston Seagull Pictures, Images and Photos

updated Dec 6, 2010
edited by Brynleigh
posted by Brynleigh
yup - margaretbl, Dec 6, 2010
1
vote

From the articles that I looked at for

Based off [of] vs based on most say that based off [of] is incorrect or substandard English.

¡Bienvenida al foro!

Welcome to the forum!

updated Dec 6, 2010
edited by 0074b507
posted by 0074b507
The fleet is based off of the coast of ... (jeje) - samdie, Dec 6, 2010
You have me there. - 0074b507, Dec 6, 2010
WE would just say in England that the fleet is based off-shore lol :) - FELIZ77, Dec 6, 2010