Home
Q&A
Por or para, please make corrections for me

Por or para, please make corrections for me

2
votes

** Im struggling with this as many do. If there is one wrong could you maybe explain why..? It's alot to ask, but would really help.**

THANKS!

I'd like that toy for Mary

Me gustaría esa juguete para Mary


Quiero viajar para diez semanas

I want to travel for 10 weeks


I'm going for an eye test

Voy por un test de visión


He votado para el presidente

I have voted for the president


El ensayo es para mañana

The essay is for tomorrow


I live for you

Vivo para ti


She leaves for school at 8.30

Se marcha para la escuela a las 8 y media


There are ten people here for the red team

Hay diez personas para el equipo rojo


They went to church for religious reasons

Fueron a la iglesia por motivos religiosos


I have been wanting to eat for hours

Había querido comer por muchas horas


Give me your apple for this orange

Dáme esa manzana por esa naranja


I want to go to Ireland for ten days

Quiero ir a Irlanda por diez días

1914 views
updated Nov 25, 2010
edited by dewclaw
posted by dewclaw
count me in for the Red Team! - mediterrunio, Nov 24, 2010

5 Answers

1
vote

I'd like that toy for Mary

Me gustaría comprar esa juguete para María correcto: para(recipient)

Quiero viajar para diez semanas Should be por (duration)

I want to travel for 10 weeks

I'm going for an eye test

Voy por un test de visión Should be para eg Voy a ir para una examen de la vista (indicating purpose) = I am going to go for an eye test

He votado para el presidente Should be por

I have voted for the president I voted You don't really need the word have here but it is not wrong. ..it just emphasises the fact that you really carried out the action

El ensayo es para mañana Correcto para (deadline)

The essay is for tomorrow

I live for you

Vivo para ti Correct para (recipient)

She leaves for school at 8.30

Se marcha para la escuela a las 8 y media Correct para I would just use Sale para escuela ....etc

There are ten people here for the red team

Hay diez personas para el equipo rojo Correct: para (The team is the recipient)

They went to church for religious reasons

Fueron a la iglesia por motivos religiosos Correct (giving reason)

I have been wanting to eat for hours Correct por (Duration)

Había querido comer por muchas horas

Give me your apple for this orange

Dáme esa manzana por esa naranja Correct por (In exchange for)

I want to go to Ireland for ten days Correct por (duration)

Quiero ir a Irlanda por diez días

Muy bien!!! grin ¡Bien hecho!

updated Nov 25, 2010
edited by FELIZ77
posted by FELIZ77
amasing answer, **** thats so helpful, thanks - dewclaw, Nov 25, 2010
I am glad you like it/consider it amazing :) Thank you fro choosing it I feel humbled :) - FELIZ77, Nov 25, 2010
2
votes

We asked it to our teacher in our lessons. We wanted to learn especially how we use para and por with people. As my teacher explains, we use "para" as we use "for" in English in the sense that it refers to our purpose. Yo compro en regalo para Elen. ( ---> para) ( I buy a gift to give Elen)

However, we use "por" when we mean we do something "because of something". For example, yo escribo una poesia por Elen. ( por

updated Nov 25, 2010
edited by yelizzz
posted by yelizzz
nice - dewclaw, Nov 25, 2010
0
votes

Se fueron*

updated Nov 24, 2010
posted by Rey_Mysterio
0
votes

votas por alguien

puedes vivir por o para alguien

puedes ir por o para una prueba

The rest seems to be perfect and yelizz suggestion is a good one

updated Nov 24, 2010
posted by mediterrunio
0
votes

Ese juguete me gustaría para Mary Quiero viajar por 10 semanas Voy a revisarme la vista Aquí hay diez personas para el equipo rojo Llevo horas queriendo comer Te cambio tu manzana por esta naranja

updated Nov 24, 2010
posted by Miren