Home
Q&A
The pants John wears.... or John wears the pants....

The pants John wears.... or John wears the pants....

2
votes

Is "The pants John wears are brown corduroy" a valid English sentence? It sounds awkward to me but I don't know what the grammar rules are. Any suggestions?

(I'll work with the Spanish translation after I get the English sentence) Gracias.

1460 views
updated Nov 18, 2010
posted by bandit51jd
Did you know Bandit - 'John wears the pants' has another meaning? It means 'he's the boss' or the one in control. - margaretbl, Nov 16, 2010
Good one, margaretbl! Yes, I've heard there is "control" when "wearing the pants"! Of course I didn't even think of that because I'm so focused on getting vocabulary and present tense verbs figured out! lol - bandit51jd, Nov 18, 2010

6 Answers

1
vote

You have identified the use of the passive and active voice. They are both grammatically correct, but the active voice is generally preferred for clarity.

Passive voice (using forms of the verb 'to be') make it less clear who is doing what to whom.

Active voice uses an action verb and makes it clear who is the actor, who is the subject and what is happening.

Click here for an explanation in English about the difference.

updated Nov 17, 2010
posted by JoyceM
JoyceM, Gracias! This active-passive voice is the grammar rule I was needing. I gather you've seen these kind of sentences before! lol - bandit51jd, Nov 16, 2010
I am an active voice enthusiast, spreading the gospel wherever I can. Using it makes your writing more dynamic. - JoyceM, Nov 17, 2010
1
vote

If he's currently wearing them I'd stick to the present progressive.

John is wearing brown corduroy pants. smile

It's a little less unwieldy.

updated Nov 16, 2010
posted by Kiwi-Girl
I go with your answer MC! - Yeser007, Nov 16, 2010
0
votes

It sounds like he wears them all the time, like the girls hair is brown.

updated Nov 16, 2010
posted by dewclaw
0
votes

Hmmm..

If John is currently wearing the pants, you might say "The pants that John is wearing are brown corduroy."

On the other hand, if you mean to say that John is partial to wearing brown corduroy, you can say "John wears brown corduroy pants."

updated Nov 16, 2010
posted by mountaingirl123
The sentence suggests that John always wears brown corduroy pants. - 0066c384, Nov 16, 2010
0
votes

It is a valid English sentence, but it might sound better to say John wears brown corduroy pants.

updated Nov 16, 2010
posted by daphne505
0
votes

That is a complete sentence in English.

updated Nov 16, 2010
posted by 0066c384