Home
Q&A
Do you stand "in line" or "on line"?

Do you stand "in line" or "on line"?

5
votes

Last month, there was a discussion about the proper terminology used when discussing the word "party" in this thread.

I thought of this again the other day while sitting in one of my favorite Manhattan diners (The Tic Toc Diner (Check it out if your in town. wink )

Anyway, someone from "way out of town" wasn't sure where to pay. A waitress told the customers to "stand on line" by the register in the back. This is the way we commonly use this expression in this part of the country. We say "stand on line"

I was standing on line at the bank.

If you want tickets for that concert, you are going to have to stand on line for hours.

The customers were of course confused until another customer shouted out "stand in line". This expression definitely predates the use of computers and has nothing to do with "going online" on a computer.

I don't think this would be called an idiom. It is just a simple change in vocabulary from region to region.

Can you think of any others in the English or Spanish language that could cause confusion to beginners(and even those who have been at it for awhile)?

alt text

12171 views
updated Jun 7, 2012
edited by Nicole-B
posted by Nicole-B
We queue ;-) - lagartijaverde, Nov 15, 2010
So the phrase would be "Join the queue" - lagartijaverde, Nov 15, 2010

24 Answers

3
votes

Seb79 said .....

In England, we wouldn't really say 'stand on line', but 'stand in line'

I've never heard that in England Seb! But to stand 'on/in line' would be easily understood (in context of course).

Here we use the verb 'to queue up' (to stand in/on line) or the noun 'queue' (the line).

Of course, queuing up is a national pastime here. I think other European people make fun of us for it tongue wink

updated Nov 15, 2010
posted by patch
Hi patch, nothing wrong with "queuing up"...well, come to think of it, we probably learned how to "form an orderly queue" from you guys :o - nonombre, Nov 13, 2010
As is "standing on line" in NYC. I think the "on" is regional. - JoyceM, Nov 15, 2010
Definitely regional Patch is correct we stand in line or queue up or form an orderly line/ queue - FELIZ77, Nov 15, 2010
2
votes

I have never in my life heard of standing "on line". I always thought "in line" made more sense because you're standing IN the formation of a line. Sometimes, I guess, there can be a physical line on the ground, but I don't think that's rarely the case... wink

updated Nov 15, 2010
posted by skygoneblue
Same here. I've heard only standing "in line" and, perhaps during my school days "stand on the line" for physical lines painted (or something) on the ground - Goldie_Miel, Nov 15, 2010
My experience is the same as Goldie's. I'm from the west coast. - Leeh, Nov 15, 2010
2
votes

Hi Nicole

For what its worth "stand in line" and that's from the country from where your language originated.

updated Nov 15, 2010
posted by Eddy
2
votes

New Yorkers and some other Eastcoasters stand on line.

Everybody else stands in line.

They just have to be better than the rest of us.

updated Nov 15, 2010
posted by Echoline
riéndome a carcajadas! - mountaingirl123, Nov 15, 2010
2
votes

New Yorkers and some other Eastcoasters stand on line.

Up as far as New England then it is "in line"

updated Nov 14, 2010
posted by Yeser007
2
votes

I say "in line". I'm from the midwest, but I've lived everywhere, currently in SoCal. "On line" sounds British to me, though I know it's not.

updated Nov 14, 2010
posted by KevinB
The answer is in line..that is proper english. - angelanimal, Nov 13, 2010
2
votes

I agree actually with patch- in England we simply use to queue, although in some circumstances I have seen 'stand in line' being used, albeit in a rather rare sense. I also think though 4annie, is correct in saying 'form an orderly queue' is used, however I think that this term is quite old-fashioned, quite 'stiff upper lipped'!.

But I suppose that's what we Brits may be seen as by other nations across the world: quite 'jolly good, old chap' with a typical British, sarcastic type accent.

An American came over to my school, to study in the first year and I couldn't help noticing how much attention he recieved because of his accent. I think it's because of the American stereo type we have here in England, of americans being rich, and therefore having a high status. I've also noticed, how in America, Americans give British individuals who visit America more attention as well, and perhaps that's due to their stereo-type of us. That of our accents being linked to having a higher intelligence.

I don't know....but it seems really interesting how certain factors attribute to how we all behave.

wink

updated Nov 13, 2010
posted by Seb79
It's true, your accent is mesmerizing to us, everyone will pay more attention to you and ask you where you're from. It just sounds so nice. :-) - athegr8, Nov 13, 2010
*From an American point of view, a British accent is very elegant. - athegr8, Nov 13, 2010
2
votes

We have a regionalism in the Chicago area.

We go "over by" things while the other parts of the country seem to go "over to" it.

For example:

"Go over by the wall and wait for someone to call your name."

Go over to the wall and wait for someone to call your name."

updated Nov 13, 2010
posted by Echoline
"Over by" possibly originated from Wales. I use it myself and is very common in the valleys. - siempre, Nov 13, 2010
1
vote

In Massachusetts we'd definitely say "stand in line," and I've never heard anyone in my travels say "standing on line."

I have heard "stoop" from my grandparents, but now it's more common to say "front/back steps" or "porch."

updated Dec 2, 2010
posted by --Mariana--
A porch is much bigger (often room for several chairs, etc.) than a stoop. - samdie, Nov 14, 2010
A stoop are the front steps to a townhouse/brownstone common in NYC and other American cities. A porch is a covered area at the top of the steps. Sitting on the stoop is an urban activity. - JoyceM, Nov 15, 2010
And "sitting on the porch" is a county/suburban activity. - samdie, Dec 2, 2010
1
vote

I'm from New York. I stand ON line at the bank, grocery store, etc. But when I hear other people say IN line, it doesn't sound strange to me. Maybe because that's what I'm used to hearing on the television.

I've read that saying "on" line is unique to the NY metropolitan area.

updated Dec 2, 2010
posted by Queue142
Welcome to the forum. - Nicole-B, Dec 2, 2010
1
vote

In line. What? yeah.

updated Nov 15, 2010
posted by jeezzle
Are you sure? I thought Texas would be supportive of "on line". jeje - Nicole-B, Nov 15, 2010
Computers? heck no. I'm connected to this via a cow named Maybelle. - jeezzle, Nov 15, 2010
1
vote

I find both entirely acceptable (along with various flavors of "queue" (perhaps I read too many British novels).

updated Nov 15, 2010
posted by samdie
1
vote

I googled "stand in line" and "stand on line". The results show about 10 times as many hits for stand in line, compared to stand on line.

http://www.google.com/search?q="stand+in+line" --> 829,000

http://www.google.com/search?q="stand+on+line" --> 85,600

This doesn't mean I always agree with google results, but it's interesting.

updated Nov 15, 2010
edited by pesta
posted by pesta
That would make sense since it seems that only a small portion of the Northeastern U.S. uses this. :) - Nicole-B, Nov 15, 2010
1
vote

In line.

updated Nov 15, 2010
posted by TheSilentHero
1
vote

In line for the Kiwis. smile alt text

updated Nov 13, 2010
posted by Kiwi-Girl
I was sure you were going to have a totally different way of saying this. I guess I was wrong. What about your neighbors the Aussies? - Nicole-B, Nov 13, 2010
We definitely stand "in line" or, in other words, we "form an orderly queue".... - nonombre, Nov 13, 2010