Home
Q&A
"She eats all the food" - is this translation even correct?

"She eats all the food" - is this translation even correct?

0
votes

I'm reading a Spanish version of The Three Bears - when Goldilocks eats all of Baby Bear's food, it says, "Se come toda la comida." I'm really confused, because I had no idea that comer could be used reflexively.

-Looking around for Lazarus- smile

Anybody have any ideas?

1564 views
updated Oct 19, 2010
posted by SiempreAprendo

4 Answers

3
votes

comerselo todo = to eat it all up

definition of pronomial verb comerse

updated Oct 19, 2010
edited by lorenzo9
posted by lorenzo9
Gracias - I appreciate the link, too! - SiempreAprendo, Oct 19, 2010
0
votes

I would guess that this is the passive voice usage, not reflexive:

"all the food was eaten".

updated Oct 19, 2010
posted by pesta
Not reflexive but not passive, either. - samdie, Oct 19, 2010
0
votes

I believe that it should read " ella come toda la comida".

updated Oct 19, 2010
posted by esperanza22
... and that's exactly what I think it should say, too! - SiempreAprendo, Oct 19, 2010
Possible but not as good as "Se come toda la comida." - samdie, Oct 19, 2010
0
votes

Lorenzo's right. Comerse is not being used reflexively. It's being used as a pronomial verb meaning, "to eat up", or "to eat all of something". The dictionary here shows this meaning.

updated Oct 19, 2010
posted by KevinB