Can I add a noun phrase to this sentence?
If I have noun phrases like: the red banjo, the woman who was laughing, it, John and that the earth is round, it seems grammatical to add them to the following to complete a sentence: "who discovered _________?". Now what about if I want to use these same noun phrases to complete a sentence like: "What I heard was _______". ? regardless of meaning or making sense, is it grammatical to fill the space with these noun phrases in the second sentence?
3 Answers
I'm also not sure I know what you're looking for, but from what you have there you can certainly say:
Who discovered that the earth is round?
What I heard was that the earth is round.
Both of those sentences make sense.
For your other sentences:
Who discovered that the red banjo was missing?
What I heard was the red banjo playing during that last song.
Who discovered that the woman who was laughing actually had too much to drink?
What I heard was the woman who was laughing earlier was crying just a few moments later.
Who discovered it?
What I heard was that it had been raining all day.
Who discovered John unconscious on the floor?
What I heard was John screaming for help.
All of these are grammatically correct. Is this what you are looking for?
Not sure I understand what you want Amando but ....but the following are good sentences.
What I heard was the red banjo.
What I heard was the woman who was laughing.
PS - I am not 100% sure but I think that all phrases that still make sense when an article is inserted into a sentence before the phrase make the phrase into a noun phrase.
Any noun clause would fit (if we ignore meaning)
What was heard was noun clause.
You are merely stating the equivalence of two noun clauses.
predicate nominative (To be is a linking verb)