Home
Q&A
would this be correct way of saying this?

would this be correct way of saying this?

1
vote

Miguel is falling 8th grade because of missing assignments and he has plagiarized an assignment:

Miguel se está quedando octavo grado, porque le faltan las tareas y ha plagiado una misión

1683 views
updated Oct 9, 2010
posted by Paul12354

5 Answers

1
vote

The "suspender" vs. "reprobar" question had me curious, so I did a google search on Mexican google. "Va a reprobar el X grado" showed up numerous times, but "va a suspender..." did not show up in that context (for Mexico - it is definitely correct in Spain). Since Kevin B wondered if you are referring to a student of American heritage, I believe his point regarding "suspender" vs. "reprobar" is a valid one.

updated Oct 9, 2010
posted by mountaingirl123
Thanks for the detective work. As an ex-part-time-teacher in a Spanglish speaking area, "suspender" just means "to suspend" around here. Kids love it. They don't have to go to school. - KevinB, Oct 9, 2010
1
vote

My attempt:

Miguel va a suspender el octavo grado porque no ha completado todos los trabajos y ha cometido plagio en uno.

Alternatively, in more "correct" Spanish:

A Miguel le van a suspender el octavo grado porque no ha completado todos los trabajos y ha cometido plagio en uno.

updated Oct 9, 2010
posted by lazarus1907
El diccionario dice que se dice 'suspender' más en España que en las Americas. ¿Es verdad? - KevinB, Oct 9, 2010
0
votes

Miguel va a suspender el octavo grado porque no ha completado todos los trabajos y ha cometido plagio en uno.

Paul, listen to Lazarus. He's a native speaker from Spain who has studied languages and grammar pretty intensely. My question to him was whether the verb "suspender" is used more in Spain than in Latin America. Regardless, this is an excellent answer, and more direct than the original.

Miguel is going to fail the eighth grade because he has not completed all his assignments and he has committed plagiarism on one.

I'd go with that.

updated Oct 9, 2010
posted by KevinB
0
votes

Welcome to the forum. I think this is a little closer. Stand by for the experts to correct me.

Miguel está reprobando el octavo grado a causa de las tareas omitidas, y ha plagiado una tarea.

Edit: Also be aware that there are differences in Spanish vocabulary depending on where you are. I assumed you were in the U.S.

updated Oct 9, 2010
edited by KevinB
posted by KevinB
0
votes

to fail

Our dictionary suggest suspender for this context. and tarea, trabajo for school assignment. It looks like you are trying to say that they will be remaining in the 8th grade which may not be a bad way to go.

¡Bienvenido al foro!

Welcome to the forum.

updated Oct 9, 2010
edited by 0074b507
posted by 0074b507