Home
Q&A
is "yo estoy jugador de básquetbol" gramatically correct?

is "yo estoy jugador de básquetbol" gramatically correct?

1
vote

is "yo estoy jugador de básquetbol" gramatically correct?

2026 views
updated Oct 26, 2010
posted by emmma

3 Answers

0
votes

.

updated Oct 26, 2010
edited by TexasLaw
posted by TexasLaw
Yes, it is wrong. - 00e657d4, Sep 26, 2010
Yes, it is wrong. - lazarus1907, Sep 26, 2010
The sentence was wong and so is your analysis of the meaning. - samdie, Sep 27, 2010
0
votes

"Estar" is not used with nouns, and "jugador" (player) is a noun, so grammatically is unacceptable.

Also, If you say "yo", it is because there is someone else other than you that we need to consider for a good reason, who is not a basketball player. If there is no need to force us to think about these other non-basketball players to whom you are not related to, you shouldn't use "yo".

updated Sep 26, 2010
edited by lazarus1907
posted by lazarus1907
"Estar" is not used with nouns - I wish someone had told me that when I started. That's very clear. - KevinB, Sep 26, 2010
0
votes

Welcome to the forum. In this case you need to use the verb ser, not estar. There are lessons here on the difference between the two. It's one of the big puzzles for beginners.

Also, most people would not say Yo. It's not needed since you can tell the subject by the conjugation of the verb, so most Spanish speakers would leave it out. It's not wrong. It is sometimes used for emphasis, but it's not typically used.

updated Sep 26, 2010
edited by KevinB
posted by KevinB