Home
Q&A
G A M E - Preterite vs Imperfect

G A M E - Preterite vs Imperfect

61
votes

Objective: practice in the use of the past tenses, preterite & imperfect

The rules:-----------------------------

  1. translate the English sentence given by the person above into Spanish using the correct preterite or imperfect verb conjugations

make sure you click on N E W E S T before you begin

Then

  1. state whether you used the preterite or the imperfect and give a short explanation as to why you used it

  • and finally
  1. provide a new sentence in English which includes a verb used in the past

for the next person to translate.

Have fun! ¡Diviértanse!

A suggestion: please keep your sentences simple. This is tricky stuff, so let's concentrate on the tenses, ok? - Gekko.

PS: here's a great link showing how the preterite is for action in the past whereas the imperfect is an ongoing condition in the past: Imperfecto vs Preterito and another that I've put together that may be of some use too, Pret vs Imp.

A big thanks to Gekko who 'was' kindly correcting this thread - Gekko if you have a mo' please post a thread below introducing yourself or post empty thread for me to introduce you, thus allowing the grateful participants to vote for all your hard and much appreciated work here wink

Edit - Sadly Gekko doesn't come round much anymore :( we'd love it if he did but in the meantime any corrections or suggestions are gratefully accepted and if someone would like to volunteer to help with moderation of this game, that'd be awesome, please just let us know so we can welcome you officially to the possie (as us antipodeans say (ie. position))

alt text

105508 views
updated Oct 25, 2014
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by Kiwi-Girl
Maria Claire, this is a great idea! I wish you lots of takers - 005faa61, Aug 10, 2010
Muchisimas gracias :) thanx for joining in! - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 10, 2010
So many views and so few posts? Come on guys just have a go - this is for learning and we're all here to help and be helped so have a crack :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
Great idea Marie-Claire :) - --Jen--, Aug 11, 2010
What a "perfect" game!!! - --Mariana--, Aug 11, 2010
Muchisimas gracias a Maria, necesito mucha practica en el preterito/el imperfecto! - schemmn, Aug 11, 2010
Why I have seen this before my quiz last night?? Oh, well final exam is tomorrow and it will be on that, too! Muchas gracias! - chica_rica, Aug 11, 2010
Great game Maria!! I think I fixed all my mistakes! Thanks to Gekko for all his help. :) - Jason7R, Aug 11, 2010
Ok peeps, I don't know about you all but I feel like my understanding of the preterite and imperfect has improved out of sight in the just the last couple of days and I'd love to do similar threads with other things - por vs para, present vs subjunctive - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
etc, so I'm begging for moderators, please, pretty please. If out of the goodness of your heart you would consider volunteering please PM me, I know many of us would be sooooo grateful :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
Wonderful game MC and thanks to Gekkosan for all his help!!! - Izanoni1, Aug 18, 2010
I know, he's the bomb isn't he lol :) but don't tell him it'll probably go to his head je je Glad you're enjoying the game :) I've learnt heaps so far! - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 18, 2010
Well done Maria, I never thought you'd get 100 answers for this. - fontanero, Aug 19, 2010
I think we all need so much help with it - have you joined in yet? Come on, give it a go, we're all getting heaps wrong, it's the best way to learn so don't be shy :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 19, 2010
Thank you Marie for you encouragement and to Gekkosan for patiently answering all my questions - sanlee, Aug 21, 2010
You're welcome :) My thanx too to Gekko, he's been very patient with us all and very, very helpful :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 25, 2010
wonderful game, marie, thanks gekko too:) - 00494d19, Sep 1, 2010
Thanx Heidita,getting the idea was pretty easy but thanks to Gekko who's doing most of the hard work ;) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 2, 2010
A great idea, I've only discovered it a day or two ago.. Good one! - annierats, Jan 12, 2012

388 Answers

1
vote

Sentence Given:
This morning I was preparing a lecture for my students but I got bored so I went out for a walk to visit my friends.
Esta mañana yo estaba preparando una conferencia para mis alumnos, pero me aburría, así que iba a visitar a mis amigos.
Ok, before I get sent to the dunce corner---I used subject pronouns to clarify the imperfect word being used!! Both the "yo" form and the "él, ella, and Ud." form uses the same conjugation in the imperfect so I was distinguishing them from each other. This should make my answer of what tense to use clear as well. There is no definite timeframe for the morning work or the time with friends. wink
Correct Revision: Esta mañana estaba preparando una lección para mis alumnos, pero me aburrí y salí a caminar y visitar a mis amigos.
New Sentence:
I went walking after midnight out in the moonlight.

updated Aug 13, 2010
edited by Jason7R
posted by Jason7R
Good Jason, we'll see what Gekko says but my suggestions would be that you could have used pasaba in the imperfect and also I would use 'salir' for going going out in the preterite because it is an action completed in the past 'salí' and visité in the - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 12, 2010
preterite for the same reason. But as I say let's see what the master says lol. - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 12, 2010
It seems to me that it should be imperfect for preparar because that is the ongoing action that was interupted by getting bored and going for a walk, so those two should be preterite. Me aburrí and fui a visitar. - sagiia, Aug 12, 2010
good point Saglia :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 13, 2010
I'm not sure you need that many "yo" in one sentence, Jason... - luz_72, Aug 13, 2010
Luz, I am assuming the first one stated would be sufficient enough for the entire sentence then? I'll take one out. Thanks :) - Jason7R, Aug 13, 2010
I agree with both María and Luz. My vesion would be: "Esta mañana estaba preparando una lección para mis alumnos, pero me aburrí y salí a (caminar y) visitar a mis amigos." Notice, no subject pronouns! Sorry, Jason, off to the DC! :-) - Gekkosan, Aug 13, 2010
Oh - and I agree with Saglia too! - Gekkosan, Aug 13, 2010
I guess my question would be...When "this morning" did the person start preparing the lecture and when did that person go to visit friends? No clear cut time, in my opinion. Thanks for teaching me something with this thread Marie!! :) - Jason7R, Aug 13, 2010
Gekk, the only reason I used subj pronouns was because of the imperfect form---to clarify, I'll change it. :) Thanks amigo - Jason7R, Aug 13, 2010
Well sometimes it's not so much of knowing the specific time, here two other criteria come into play - as Sagiia said if you're doing something and it get's interrupted then you must use the imperfect for the first and preterite for the ones doing the - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 13, 2010
interrupting. Also if you list a sequence of actions in the past then you need to use the preterite. Hope those rules help :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 13, 2010
1
vote

Old sentence: Remember the man who was called Paul and who wore glasses? Well, he got very sick and he nearly died.

¿Recuerdas al hombre que se llamaba Paul y que usaba gafas? Pues estuvo muy enfermo y casi muere

*** Correction thanks to Gekko: so, estuvo is preterit because he was sick at one time and we assume he's better now? Why is muere in present tense when it's in past tense in the original? (My other guess was maybe it should be subjunctive because it wasn't reality, he didn't really die, but I think I'm 6 kinds of confused about subjunctive right now. grin )

Not as sure about this one... not sure if "remember" should be recordar or acordarse, and if "estar" can have the meaning of "get" or "become" sick. The next 3 verbs are imperfect because they happened in general (all throughout his lifetime).


New sentence: Did you know that last month was my parents' anniversary? They were traveling at that time, so they probably didn't celebrate it then!

updated Aug 13, 2010
edited by schemmn
posted by schemmn
I would say 'got sick' denotes a change in physical state so I'm thinking it should take the preterite - se enfermó - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
Another way to say get sick would be ponerse enfermo. - sagiia, Aug 12, 2010
I'd suggest the following translation. Perhaps the times will be clearer that way: ¿Recuerdas al hombre que se llamaba Paul y que usaba gafas? Pues estuvo muy enfermo y casi muere. - Gekkosan, Aug 12, 2010
oh good I was wondering what should follow casi - thanx G - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 12, 2010
1
vote

Given: Last week I had a job interview, and I thought I didn't do too well, but yesterday they called me and offered the job!

La semana pasada tuve una entrevista de trabajo y pensé que no me había ido muy bien, pero ayer me llamaron y me ofrecieron el trabajo!

I have used the preterite for each verb (except creer)because they are all completed actions in the past. I have to admit I vacilated between the preterite and imperfect for 'creer' but ending up going with the imperfect because he believed it for an unstated, unspecified period of time.

(but I am still learning so would be happy for any suggestions or corrections -- darn, just when I thought I was getting it - I think I'm over-thinking it lol smile )

New sentence:

actually I'm going to put two for you to choose from - an easier one if you're just beginning and a harder one if you want to really be tested smile

> When you went to school were you a good child?

or

Mary tried to buy the house but John didn't want her to buy it.

updated Aug 12, 2010
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by Kiwi-Girl
That looks like how I'd imagined it! (& btw, I'm a she, not a he :-) -- no offense taken.) - schemmn, Aug 11, 2010
gr8 :) I must be missing something though - did I think you were a he? - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
only said that because you mentioned in your post "...because he believed it...", but maybe you were using the generic "he" and not referring to me. Got to love internet mis-communication, jaja! :-) - schemmn, Aug 11, 2010
ja ja lol - I thought it was just a random sentence not a personal one sorry :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
"Creía que no lo hizo muy bien" is not correct, María. "I" had the interview, not a third person. Think you can fix it? Oh, and you should use the ver "ir", instead of "hacer"... :-) - Gekkosan, Aug 12, 2010
ok so I changed it to fui, is that right? so it says 'I didn't go very well' but would it be wrong to say 'no fue' as in 'it' the interview' didn't go well? And as per your correction you can't say I didn't 'do' well, it has to be 'go'?? - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 12, 2010
I'm difficult I know! :p - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 12, 2010
..."y pensé que no me había ido muy bien, pero ayer..." - Gekkosan, Aug 12, 2010
1
vote

My dog used to dig in the yard until we bought her some toys to play with.

Mi perro solía cavar en el patio hasta la compráremos algunos juguetes para jugar.

IMPERFECT-- ' used to' indicates the sentence tells about habitual action.

When I was 6 year's old, my family lived in Delhi.

updated Aug 12, 2010
posted by Ashis
Ashis, I posted the same answer below. You can check your translation with mine, if you wish. - Gekkosan, Aug 12, 2010
Great try Ashis, as Gekko pointed out it's handy how the imperfect form of the verb can carry the meaning of 'used to' rather than having to use soler. Also I think that when hasta and para are followed by a verb they need que as in Gekko's answer :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 12, 2010
0
votes

Given: When I was in fourth grade I almost flunked handwriting and physical education, but I didn't know because the grading system in California was complicated..

Translated: Cuando era en cuarto grado, casi saqué malas notas en caligrafía e education física, pero no lo sabía porque el sistema de grado era complicado.

Corrected: Cuando estaba en cuarto curso (I'm taking curso from an example in the Dictionary), casi suspendí caligrafía y educación física, pero no lo sabía porque el sistema de clasificación era complicado.

Reason: The first "estaba" is imperfect because it is describing a scene, "suspendí" because it is a completed action, sabía because its over an unspecified time, and the last era because we are describing it.

New: I wanted to tell you something, but now I don't because I forgot what I wanted to say.

updated Feb 7, 2012
edited by BradyLabuda
posted by BradyLabuda
Another brave attempt on a difficult sentence. The first was must be "estar", not "ser". A different expression is needed for "flunk" - tricky, because this is an idiomatic expression. "y" educación física. Different word for "grading". - Gekkosan, Feb 7, 2012
0
votes

Given: Because I was fired from my job last week, I applied to several businesses downtown.

Translation: La semana pasada fui despedido de mi empleo, y por eso solicitaba a algunas empresas en el centro del pueblo.

2nd effort, after helpful hints: La semana pasada fui despedido de mi trabajo y , por eso, solicitaba trabajo a algunas empresas en el centro del pueblo.

Reason: The being fired was a one off happening, but the applying for jobs is on-going. And I have no idea what down-town is, I'm just guessing a bit. The por is a guess, maybe it should be 'a'?

New Sentence: All the businesses turned me down so I decided to commit suicide, there and then.

updated Jan 11, 2012
edited by annierats
posted by annierats
Izantoni is right, I gave up immediately they didn't give me a new job and that's why I decided to commit suicide. - annierats, Jan 11, 2012
Hi annie. The verb "solicitar" is transitive which means it should be followed by a direct object describing what it was you were asking/looking for (in this case, you were searching for "employment/a job") - Izanoni1, Jan 11, 2012
Of the choice between "por" and "a," I would suggest that "a" would be the better choice as it could be used to introduce the person or company as an indirect object (i.e. the person/company "to whom" you made this request for employment) - Izanoni1, Jan 11, 2012
Downtown could have been just be 'around the town' or 'businesses in my town'. Same idea. - Jadey7, Jan 11, 2012
Gracias Ianzoni y Jadey, I've had another go... - annierats, Jan 11, 2012
0
votes

Given: "When I was in Barcelona, I spent all the time watching football matches."

updated Jan 8, 2012
posted by Mndeen75
Hi Mndeen, nice to have you join in, the way to play is to click 'newest' then you translate the sentence that the last person left and after giving the reason why you used the preterite or imperfect you leave a new past tense English sentence. :) - Kiwi-Girl, Jan 8, 2012
Bestgirl wasn't too sure how to play either so technically this was the last sentence given that you might like to translate: After a long trip he arrived in a small town and he was very hungry. - Kiwi-Girl, Jan 8, 2012
0
votes

de niño jugaba las munñecas de mi hermana when i was a child i used to play with my sister's dolls imperfect

updated Jan 8, 2012
edited by -bestgirl98-
posted by -bestgirl98-
Hi Bestgirl, nice to have you join in - the way to play is to click 'newest' then you translate the sentence that the last person left and after giving the reason why you used the preterite or imperfect you leave a new past tense English sentence. :) - Kiwi-Girl, Jan 8, 2012
would you like to edit your post and have another go? This was the last sentence: After a long trip he arrived in a small town and he was very hungry. - Kiwi-Girl, Jan 8, 2012
0
votes

Given: The woman looked exactly like a young Marilyn Monroe but something seemed wrong.

Translation: La mujer se veía exactamente como una joven Marilyn Monroe, pero había algo extraño.

New Sentence: Although the woman was very beautiful, she had a striking resemblance to Frankenstein, as though she had just been created.

alt text

updated Apr 23, 2011
edited by 001a2987
posted by 001a2987
"miraba" here is the wrong translation for look in this context. You'd need another option with the reflexive. ;-) "Pareció equivocada" doesn't work either. Great picture! - Gekkosan, Apr 19, 2011
Thanks Gekko...hopefully this is better...I replaced miraba with parecía, and instead of saying "seemed wrong", I said "seemed strange"? Ojalá es mejor? - 001a2987, Apr 19, 2011
Better, but not quite there yet. :-) Try "ver" for looked (same rule as before), and try the imperfect at the end. - Gekkosan, Apr 19, 2011
¿Es mejor ahora? ....y como siempre, muchas gracias!! - 001a2987, Apr 20, 2011
Well Marilyin was female, right? (Monroe, not Manson!) You really need to pay attention to those gender agreements. :-) I'd say: "Pero había / tenía algo extraño" - Gekkosan, Apr 20, 2011
Wow, I guess I definitely have some holes in my Spanish that I need to address...but as always, thanks for helping!! :) - 001a2987, Apr 23, 2011
0
votes

Given My kids almost didn't make it to soccer because I had forgotten about their practice.

Mis niños casi se pierden el fútbol porque se me había olvidado que tenían práctica.

I did what Gekko said and used a different tense.

New He almost missed a doctor appointment and the last time he missed one the charge him fifty dollars.

updated Oct 14, 2010
edited by sanlee
posted by sanlee
I'm not sure you can use 'made it' like that Sandy, perhaps llegar would be better? - Kiwi-Girl, Oct 11, 2010
also, hicieron is the preterite form of hacer not the imperfect :) Want to have another go? - Kiwi-Girl, Oct 11, 2010
Absolutely, Maria-Claire! - sanlee, Oct 11, 2010
Mis niños casi no llegaban al fútbol porque se me olvidé sus practica. - sanlee, Oct 11, 2010
I think when you use the structure "a mi se me olvidó...." that impersonal form, the verb has to be conjugated in the 3rd person i.e "the practice forgot itself (to me)". I know that looks extremely clumsy in English, I hope it makes sense. - Ralf_Schnurrbartwachser, Oct 12, 2010
Mis niños casi no llegaban al fútbol porque se me olvidó sus practica. - sanlee, Oct 12, 2010
Do I have to actually write Mis niños casi no llegaban al fútbol porque a mi se me olvidó? - sanlee, Oct 12, 2010
I think arriving needs to be in the preterite as it is a one off action at a particular moment and as the English one says had forgotten I think you will need a 'perfect' version :) - Kiwi-Girl, Oct 13, 2010
You guys did a good job figuring out some of the problems. The problem is that this sentence translates better in a different tense. A more natural contruction for me would be: - Gekkosan, Oct 13, 2010
"Mis niños casi se pierden el fútbol porque se me había olvidado que tenían práctica." I know, it's not very close in terms of the literal, but the literal sounds weird to me. :-) - Gekkosan, Oct 13, 2010
Thanks Gekko :) - Kiwi-Girl, Oct 13, 2010
Thanks, Gekko. So what tenses are they? Pierden is regular present tense, right? and habia is imperfect, there must be a preterit in there somewhere because he did forget and that is completed past action, right? - sanlee, Oct 14, 2010
0
votes

Given Sentence

Her mother found out her daughter was engaged when she looked at the boyfriend's facebook page and saw the words, "She said, 'Yes!' ".

Su madre descubrió que su hija se había comprometido cuando vió la página de facebook del novio y vio las palabras, ' Ella dijo, ' ¡Sí! " '.

Estuvo prometida is imperfect because continuing past action (had not happened has of that time) All the rest are preterit because past action completed and story narration

New Sentence It was August 8, 2008, the day my son got married, and I was very happy.

updated Sep 25, 2010
edited by sanlee
posted by sanlee
"su hija estaba comprometida" - imperfect. Now, a note about this particular translation. The way you wrote it, with the correction I provided, is literally correct - but opens itself to an awkward ambiguity. "su hija estaba comprometida" can be read as.. - Gekkosan, Sep 23, 2010
"her daughter was compromised", which definitely is rather awkward. I would rephrase the translation so that it reads something like: "descubrió que su hija se había comprometido cuando vió.." - Gekkosan, Sep 23, 2010
Have marriage on your mind lately, eh? - Gekkosan, Sep 23, 2010
This is actually at true story. I looked at my daughter's boyfriend's facebook page and found out that she was engaged - sanlee, Sep 23, 2010
I was trying to make interesting sentences, Gekkosan. Everyone is married in our family. - sanlee, Sep 23, 2010
escubrió que su hija se había comprometido cuando vió. I think I fixed it, Gekkosan - sanlee, Sep 25, 2010
0
votes

Given: When we were first married, we made bookshelves out of wood and used them as dressers for our clothes by putting curtains on the front of them.

Cuando eramos recién casados, hicimos unas estanterías de madera, pusimos las cortinas en la parte delantera y las usábamos como cómodas para nuestras ropas.

I have a feeling this has some problems and I was a bit liberal with changing the word order around, but I think that the meaning is maintained.

'eramos' is imperfect because it has no clear start or end, it also is the action that is taking place when the other actions happen 'hicimos' is preterite as it is a singular, competed action 'pusimos' is in the same series of events as 'hacer' 'usábamos' is imperfect because the action was ongoing with no clear start or end

New sentence: When I saw him, I couldn't believe how big he'd gotten.

updated Sep 22, 2010
posted by la-maestra-roja
Ser & Estar strikes once more. Dear me... "Cuando estábamos..." "..pusimos unas..." "y las usamos como..." - Gekkosan, Sep 20, 2010
I like the way in which you turned the lasp part of the sentence around to make it more natural. I think it works very well. - Gekkosan, Sep 20, 2010
lasp? is that a new spanglish word? - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 20, 2010
I'd better not catch you making a typo *ever*, Missy! Do you harass Heidita the same way, I wonder? Ohhh, the stuff a poor , suffering moderator has to put up with! - Gekkosan, Sep 22, 2010
0
votes

When to use the preterite and the present in spanish especially when asking a question

updated Sep 20, 2010
posted by lnelle
Hello, Inelle, welcome to the Forum. This is really not the best place to ask that question, since this is a game for practicing the preterite and the imperfect tenses. You may post a quesion in the may "Answers" page, or you may do a search for.... - Gekkosan, Sep 17, 2010
...the topics that interest you. - Gekkosan, Sep 17, 2010
what a lovely friendly and helpful comment Gekko, what's happened to you, jeje just kidding :P - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 17, 2010
I like to lure them in, make them feel safe and cozy.. and then I strike! :-] - Gekkosan, Sep 20, 2010
nasty! - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 20, 2010