Home
Q&A
How you doing?

How you doing?

3
votes

Deseo saber si la expresión " How you doing? " es correcta, y si se considera en el buen Inglés, o es una frase idiomática tal vez. Les agradezco de antemano cuaquier orientación al respecto.

1407 views
updated Aug 1, 2010
posted by rodolfo-cabrera

5 Answers

4
votes

Hi rodolfo

Your phrase probably comes about from where we use abbreviations. "How are you doing" can be abbreviated to "how´re you doing". When this is said quickly, the ´re disappears and you finish with "how you doing".

updated Aug 1, 2010
edited by Eddy
posted by Eddy
Whoa. Very true. I can't believe no one had thought of that yet (or at least posted it). :) - chaparrito, Jul 31, 2010
Muchas gracias, la explicación es muy precisa. - rodolfo-cabrera, Aug 1, 2010
3
votes

La frase correcta es "How are you doing?", pero muchas veces la gente perezosa dice "How you doing?". Esta no es correcta, pero es común.

updated Aug 1, 2010
edited by KevinB
posted by KevinB
Buena explicación Kevin! Muchas gracias. - rodolfo-cabrera, Aug 1, 2010
3
votes

Creo que si fuera un libro titulado 'La gramática correcta de la gente de Bronx en Nueva York', ese contendría la expresión "How you doin'?" (sin la 'g') wink Es tan común en ciertas secciones de esta ciudad que, al decir "How are you doing", el orador se identificaría como extranjero.

updated Aug 1, 2010
posted by chaparrito
Bronx vernacular: "How ya doin'?" ;-) - amykay, Jul 31, 2010
Exactly, but it sounds more like: Howyoodoowin? ;-) - chaparrito, Jul 31, 2010
yup!! - amykay, Jul 31, 2010
Gracias chaparrito! - rodolfo-cabrera, Aug 1, 2010
3
votes

Hi! The correct phrase in English is:

"How are you doing?"

Your sentence was lacking a verb.

Bienvenido al foro!

updated Aug 1, 2010
posted by amykay
Gracias amykay! - rodolfo-cabrera, Aug 1, 2010
2
votes

It's just sloppy English, but understandable and used by people that are too lazy to use proper grammar. It sounds more informal and casual. A person might use it, even though, he knows that it is not the proper way to phrase it to sound more friendly.

Of course, "How are you doing?" is the proper way to state it, but it sounds formal in certain contexts.

Similarly, we often say "How are you?" rather than "How are you doing", just because it sounds less formal.

updated Aug 1, 2010
posted by 0074b507
Muchs gracias Quentin! - rodolfo-cabrera, Aug 1, 2010