Home
Q&A
Are negative tú commands formed the exact same way as the tú present subjunctive form?

Are negative tú commands formed the exact same way as the tú present subjunctive form?

1
vote

I know that when forming the negative tú commands you use the present tú form but use the opposite ending, but it doesn't seem like that is always true. So does it work to always just use the tú present subjunctive for the negative command?

For example, when i say Don't eat! I would say no comas, and comas is the present subjunctive. so does it always work that way?

2859 views
updated May 30, 2010
posted by AmyMardis

3 Answers

1
vote

As far as I know you are correct in stating that the negative tú commands always use the tú present subjunctive for the tú negative command. I just did a quick check through a list of irregular vebs and did not find any exceptions to this rule.

This seems to be the reason why the negative tú commands are not shown in the verb conjugations on this Web site!

updated May 30, 2010
edited by Pajaro44
posted by Pajaro44
1
vote

I believe that when a negative command is given, the present subjunctive for all persons singular and plural is used. It is the affirmative commands that require a little more effort in order to learn especially as there are ten or so basic irregular verbs in which the tú form is very irregular.

The most commonly used verbs seem to be the most irregular - I suppose that makes sense really!

updated May 30, 2010
posted by aeroplod
0
votes

Pajaro said

As far as I know you are correct in stating that the negative tú commands always use the tú present subjunctive for the tú negative command.

I would add to this that when the negative command is used the object pronoun is never attached to the end as in the positive imperative.

Example: Don't tell him - No le digas (familiar form)

updated May 30, 2010
posted by Eddy