Home
Q&A
Por o para? ...A Challenge: post in English and Spanish

Por o para? ...A Challenge: post in English and Spanish

6
votes

I love challenges but I have not been too lucky here at getting something going but I am not giving up. Since por y para are a challenge to all learners of spanish, I thought we might like a little practice.

Wtrite your sentences in English and Spanish.

And don't forget: Don't use subject pronouns in Spanishwink

Sentence: El hombre salió para Madrid. (The man left for Madrid.)

This is the reference site to help participating members find everything about "por y para" on spanishdict.com:

Spanishdict para and por

2611 views
updated May 30, 2010
edited by 00494d19
posted by foxluv
This thread is monitored by Nila. - 00494d19, May 23, 2010
*cite (not "site") - Luciente, May 23, 2010
I think the instructions were too complicated so I have altered them, this is a good thread, and I hope you get it right, our native speaker Nila is moderating this thread, so let's do it! - 00494d19, May 26, 2010
Gracias Heidita, good idea! - foxluv, May 26, 2010

10 Answers

2
votes

Let's just post a sentence, let'¡s see if you get it right, you can also post one with para one with por....let's see how it works.

Lo hice por ti. I did it in your place, instead of youwink

Lo hice para ti. I did it for yougrin

updated Jun 3, 2010
posted by 00494d19
Nice diistinction that hadn't occurred to me! - galsally, May 28, 2010
2
votes

Rule: Para is used to indicate a destination

Rule: Por is used to indicate "by way of" or "through" or "via"

Sentence: Mañana, voy a salir para Lima, Perú por Miami. (Tomorrow, I am going to leave for Lima, Peru by way of/via Miami.)

updated May 23, 2010
edited by Pajaro44
posted by Pajaro44
OK. - nila45, May 23, 2010
1
vote

Rule: "para" to indicate a purpose.

Sentence: El está ahorrando para comprar un coche (he is saving to buy a car)

updated May 26, 2010
edited by nila45
posted by nila45
1
vote

Este coche es para mi hijo Rule: To indicate a recipient, use para

updated May 26, 2010
posted by redassassin00
English translation, por favor. - foxluv, May 20, 2010
Well done. - nila45, May 23, 2010
1
vote

I like it: Por aqui hay mucha gente buena. Rule: Location is vague - use por

updated May 23, 2010
posted by margaretbl
Since "por aquí" is an idiomatic expression, the rule wouldn't really apply. - foxluv, May 20, 2010
It could be "aquí" o "por aquí". - nila45, May 23, 2010
0
votes

Lee para tí

Read to yourself

updated May 30, 2010
posted by nila45
0
votes

Loquito por tí - I know this from a song, but it seems it should be 'para', no?

Estoy confundida. confused

Ok I found it - Por for emotions!

He comprado este perro para tí...?
Does it need the indirect object pronoun or not?

updated May 30, 2010
edited by nila45
posted by galsally
It can be "te he comprado este perro" o "he comprado este perro para tí" - nila45, May 27, 2010
Galsally, "¿loquito para tí?". But, that doesn't exit. It is not a recipient. I don't give anything to that person. - nila45, May 30, 2010
0
votes

No lo haría por nada del mundo.

I wouldn`t do it for anything in the world.

updated May 27, 2010
posted by 00494d19
0
votes

From a Spanish folksong, "Yo subí al pino más alto / por ver si la divisaba (bis)." It certainly looks like 'purpose'. The only counter argument (in favor of 'por') that I can think of is an appeal to the metrics of the song.

updated May 27, 2010
posted by samdie
From my point of view "para" would be for a purpose and "por" is for the reason. On some occasions, it is not so easy to distinguish if it is the purpose or the reason in this sentence but it is usually "para" (purpose). - nila45, May 27, 2010
0
votes

Rule: use "por" for an motivation

"Gracias por ayudarme." (Thank you for helping me)

"Gracias por todo." (Thank you for everything)

updated May 24, 2010
edited by nila45
posted by --Mariana--
That is good. - nila45, May 24, 2010