Home
Q&A
nos quedan 100 pesos

nos quedan 100 pesos

2
votes

Hola!

Distinguishing reflexive verb and direct object/indirect object is something that I really have problems dealing with in Spanish. Please bear with me.

nos quedan 100 pesos

If I am to understand this sentence, I might interpret it as They left us 100 pesos.

But someone told me its we have 100 pesos left. Is there some technique I should follow whenever I read sentences in Spanish so that I will better understand the sentences I'm reading? Thank you!

3107 views
updated Apr 5, 2011
edited by yuriandre
posted by yuriandre

3 Answers

1
vote

They left us 100 pesos.

That would probably use the verb dejar; not quedar.

If you look in our dictionary quedar isn't used transitively except for in one minor context that they don't even give a sample sentence for. So they left the 100 pesos is not correct. The 100 pesos can't be a direct object, but must be the subject.

The "someone" is our dictionary. You question is a sample sentence for intransitive use. quedar

The RAE definition shows only intransitive or pronominal usage, no transitive uses.

quedar-RAE

updated May 10, 2010
edited by 0074b507
posted by 0074b507
Thanks a lot, Greed! :D When you say transitive, it means, it needs an object right? - yuriandre, May 10, 2010
Yes, a transitive sentence has a direct object in it. - 0074b507, May 10, 2010
Thanks! :D - yuriandre, May 10, 2010
1
vote

Both are right and depend on context, just if you add "se". Se queda (3 person singular) or se quedan (3 person plural) means the same when they are used as "it is left". And "nos quedan" - they left us.

updated May 10, 2010
posted by swing
0
votes

I see. Thank you. smile

updated May 10, 2010
posted by yuriandre