Home
Q&A
Participation required, why do only a few people answer threads?

Participation required, why do only a few people answer threads?

30
votes

I noticed that up to 150 members can read a question, yet only 4 or 5 answer it, mostly always the same. And out of all those not many actually vote for a good question or answer.

What's up with that people, shy, too busy, have nothing to say? In my opinion the more you participate in a community the more you get out of it...and that's the free gift. Everybody here is so friendly, the only risk you are taking by answering a question is to give the wrong answer and someone will politely give you the correct answer, yet another gift as you will go to bed having learned something.

So...vamos amigos y amigas...participation is a winner cool smile

8117 views
updated Apr 19, 2011
edited by sfrenchie
posted by sfrenchie
Frenchie, lo he cambiado para que quede claro en tema, quieres que te corrijan el inglés? - 00494d19, May 6, 2010
hehe, I like how many votes this thread is getting, you seem to have guilted everyone into voting!! - --Jen--, May 6, 2010
Glad you asked. The issue has been touched in serveral threads, but the question wanted asking. ...and you're getting lots of responses and votes! :-) - Gekkosan, May 6, 2010
Thx, I liked my title/question better though, more flashy jaja - sfrenchie, May 6, 2010
Getting votes for myself was not my goal but I appreciate and I am flattered. - sfrenchie, May 6, 2010

30 Answers

7
votes

I've started threads and they would be buried five pages back within a few minutes. I've answered questions and a lot of times those threads would die and I would never know if the person was helped or not.

There's not much encouragment to participate in threads like that. There are some people here that ask one question after another and bombard the forum, so the other threads get pushed back a couple of pages in a matter of minutes.

This site is bombard with threads of simplistic questions that could be answered by either using the dictionary or the translator. Laziness.

updated Oct 24, 2010
posted by Jack-OBrien
32
votes

I only refrain from answering a question when 1) I don't know the answer; or 2) someone has already given the answer and I have nothing new to add.

I, too, wonder why people don't vote more. It costs nothing to give your vote to a game or topic that interests you. Sometimes, I see a game that has 150 responses and gets only 9 votes. How is that possible?

Please people...vote more!!

updated Sep 19, 2011
posted by --Mariana--
Couldn't agree more!! :) - Jason7R, May 6, 2010
What Marianne said. :-) - Gekkosan, May 6, 2010
I agree with you. However, I also notice that some of us tend to answer multiple times, which adds a small explanation, but there are many who do not vote. - danrivera, May 6, 2010
For explanation of a term I feel comfortable with 5 to 10 answers, open discussions are different of course. - sfrenchie, May 6, 2010
Jeje, now you have a lot of votes Marianne! - April-Sarah, May 6, 2010
Sometimes it's a bit dissapointing if you ask a question and only get about 2 answers and a couple of votes. - April-Sarah, May 6, 2010
that's exactly what I do marianne...and most of the time, that's the case with every question i look at! - hlsbookworm, May 6, 2010
i completely agree!! :) - lauren12, May 6, 2010
They did in this thread, didn't they! - LateToDinner, Jul 4, 2010
This almost looks like a legendary answer, someone has to come along and vote. - LateToDinner, Jul 4, 2010
Most times I just don't know the answer to the question :-p - crazy_for_sugar, Jul 4, 2010
21
votes

To be honest, I don't answer more posts because a. I don't know the answer, or b. it's already been answered comprehensively and any more posts would be superfluous, (very like this post, as I'm just echoing what everyone else has already said!)

I'm also cripplingly shy when it comes to making mistakes, so if I'm unsure of anything I tend to wait for someone much more experienced that I to come along smile.

Oh, and also, I'm frequently on here when I'm supposed to be revising and it makes me feel better if there's no evidence that I was being a procrastinator! red face LOL

updated Oct 28, 2010
edited by --Jen--
posted by --Jen--
I feel your pain. I used to be very shy. I literally made myself change and thus far it has been all benefit - sfrenchie, May 6, 2010
you have just perfectly described me.... - hlsbookworm, May 6, 2010
I couldn't have said it better myself! - DaddysBabyGirl, Oct 24, 2010
16
votes

It seems you are forgetting that many of us beginners that are reading the posts ( to get involved, to learn, to get a feel for a good post) are not allowed to vote. Pure and simple.

And when you say "4 or 5, mostly the same" the part about mostly the same is reinforcement for me - at this early stage I don't need to be any more confused than I am!

Fabulous site ... thank you all!

updated Jul 6, 2010
edited by LateToDinner
posted by LateToDinner
Yes, that's silly, and it's another reason that I try to give votes to newbies right away. - --Mariana--, May 6, 2010
I started only 2 weeks ago if that much and never felt the restriction, didn't even know it existed - sfrenchie, May 6, 2010
Thanks to your question and Marianne's support, it took about 2 minutes for that restriction to disappear. But you must have already earned reputation points to be able to vote. - LateToDinner, May 7, 2010
But your theme is right on: Participate. - LateToDinner, Jul 6, 2010
10
votes

Can I mention that we should vote up more first time posts. No matter how inane or poorly worded the question (unless slanderous or inappropriate) the user deserves some encouragement to further participate in the forum. I think that we are fairly consistent with welcoming new members to the forum, but I think that if the person tried to participate in the forum we can, at least, not let him continue on with 0 reputation points.

updated Jun 4, 2011
posted by 0074b507
I vote for newbies as well, just to give them a start on the forum with the first 10 points. - --Mariana--, May 6, 2010
Ditto! - LaBurra, May 6, 2010
This is my policy as well Quentin. I don't know how many continue on because of that vote, but hopefully some are encouraged to participate again. - Nicole-B, May 6, 2010
Well, you got me started and now you can't stop me anymore LOL - sfrenchie, May 6, 2010
I am with you on that - nizhoni1, May 6, 2010
Questions, yes. Answers, definitely not. - Luciente, May 6, 2010
I agree Q and almost always vote up a newbies question. Kind of a welcome thing. - Yeser007, May 6, 2010
Well said. - galsally, May 8, 2010
10
votes

Hi Frenchie,

I don't think it's necessary that all of us answer every single question; no need for that and it will only create confusion. I personally restrain myself from answering because I'm not very confident in my Spanish and I believe that wrong answer can be more misleading than no answer at all. But I do take part in almost all games and challenges.

I agree with the voting part, we should vote more generously.

updated Jun 9, 2010
posted by luz_72
Agree with everything here. I'm not confident in my Spanish and I feel that on a learning site a wrong answer is worse than no answer. But I vote, frequently. - Lrtward, May 6, 2010
Same here! - mar959, May 6, 2010
Yes and no Luz. There is a very efficient way of teaching that is starting from wrong and explain why. It usually opens up to more learning than just having the correct answer to start with. - sfrenchie, May 6, 2010
10
votes

Sometimes I look and don't reply because I think the question has been answered sufficiently already or I don't know the answer. Sometimes I don't reply because it's a topic I don't want to get involved in, but that doesn't happen very often.

I almost always chuck in a vote, and sometimes vote for more than one post - I don't know if that's ok or not!!

updated May 8, 2010
posted by galsally
Yes, it's OK. You can vote for all the answers that you consider good! - Gekkosan, May 6, 2010
Thanks for clarifying that. :) - galsally, May 8, 2010
9
votes

Fear of giving an answer that is incorrect or criticized by others.

updated Jul 4, 2010
posted by ocbizlaw
I have yet to see a personal criticism on this site - sfrenchie, May 6, 2010
Not having seen it vs. having 'fear of' are not the same... a fear that Mr. Law and I share. - LateToDinner, Jun 9, 2010
8
votes

I agree with you Frenchie that we need to vote more diligently for one another. Of course the rule is to vote for high quality questions and answers. But I see so many high quality threads and answers that receive minimal participation and few votes. I am always amazed when I see intelligent, useful threads opened that have only one or two votes. Some of these threads have tons of answers already. If a thread is worthy of so many answers, than I think the number of votes should be roughly the same. Members may vote an unlimited number of times each day. It takes very little energy to click "vote". It is very confusing to me why people don't vote more.

*I know there are the usual arguments that people are not interested in points, badges, etc. They are only here to learn. Well that is very true. I would say the majority of us are here because we want to improve our Spanish/English or to help others who are in that process. However, there are many things we all do each day, not looking for a reward. We take care of our families, do kind things for friends and even strangers on occasion. Although we are not doing these things for the reward of compliments, it is nice to occasionally receive that sort of feedback from others.

This is a community of people who are here to learn and help others learn. Wouldn't it be nice if we encouraged each other a bit more? This can be done through participation in threads, encouraging comments....and of course voting for each other.

alt text

updated May 8, 2010
edited by Nicole-B
posted by Nicole-B
Vote Pedro - sfrenchie, May 6, 2010
For example, Swing's threads Song of the Week, is disappointingly underattended I M O, a lot of effort goes into it. - galsally, May 8, 2010
7
votes

I always vote for all answers .

I agree with quesito, it is best to vote good answers, the other way even wrong answers might be accepted.

And please also "accept" answers! Such few answers are accepted !!

updated May 6, 2010
posted by 00494d19
I agree with this. The best answers should go to the top. Sadly though, a lack of voting and accepting keeps some great answers from making it to the top. - Nicole-B, May 6, 2010
What does accepting an answer do? - sfrenchie, May 6, 2010
20 more points - nizhoni1, May 6, 2010
yes, that's right. we definetely need to do more "Accepting". - April-Sarah, May 6, 2010
As long as they realize they should N O T accept game answers. - Yeser007, May 6, 2010
7
votes

A lot of the time I read the thread to learn, not to answer the original poster's question.

There is a thread here now, for example, about tocar vs. golpear especially as the two terms relate to knocking on a door. The responses were informative to me, and I learned something. But I had nothing to contribute by posting a response to that thread.

updated May 6, 2010
posted by Lrtward
As long as you voted to thank the authors :0) - sfrenchie, May 6, 2010
7
votes

Seems to boil down to a mix of personality - am I an answerer or a reader and practicality - I don't answer if I have nothing more to say.

My question would be - does this forum exist simply to answer questions like "how do I translate elephant" -> "un elefante" - end of show - or does it provide us with an excuse to communicate with each other at the same time that we provide answers and help out?

Personally I lean a very long way to the latter. Apart from enjoying the interaction, I am convinced that the questioner will be more likely to remember the answer if I dress it up a little.

updated May 6, 2010
edited by geofc
posted by geofc
Indeed I think we all benefit more from the latter. - sfrenchie, May 6, 2010
7
votes

Gracias por aclarar este asunto, la verdad tenía la idea que hacía falta dar los votos con moderación (no sé de dónde mi vino esa idea) ¡pues ahora voy a volverme loca votando a gusto!

updated May 6, 2010
posted by margaretbl
7
votes

In answer to your query, I am often too late to add anything to what has already been given, especially if the answers are extremely comprehensive. Often, I add comments rather than opening another answer box. I probably don't take the time (and really, how much time does it take red face ) to vote, I'll try to do better on that.

updated May 6, 2010
posted by Delores--Lindsey
Also, sometime it is a question that I have had, and I just want to see the answer! :-) - Delores--Lindsey, May 6, 2010
Thank you Delores. As you may see I take the time to do that as well, little personal touch to thank all for their response - sfrenchie, May 6, 2010
6
votes

Thank you all so much for your answers and opinions. First let me say that I do not vote for all answers but it was late when I put up my original post and I forgot to include the word "educative." To me voting is not intended to compete in a points race but rather to say, "thank you for taking time sharing your knowledge. Because of you I learned something and I appreciate it."

As for answering questions, should we (us beginners) even attempt to open our mouth (keyboard) and take the risk of making fools of ourselves? My position on this is YES. Where I am from they say, "ridiculous doesn't kill." If the subject is way over my head you will not see my name in the posts but if I know even a little part of the answer I will post. The worse that can happen is that someone will say "tss tss tss Frenchie, that's not it" and they will give the right answer. In term it will motivate me to learn it since I hate being wrong LOL.

Should we reply to questions already answered? Sometimes we can, if it adds to the subject/explanation, maybe to insert an anecdote or personal experience. Also I have taught college at some point and noticed that often it is beneficial to explain several times using different routes. In any case there is no punishment or blame for posting, so why not.

Finally can someone tell me what Accepting an answer does?

updated Oct 24, 2010
posted by sfrenchie
Accepting adds 20 points to the "best" answer - nizhoni1, May 6, 2010
The accepted answer is also put to the very top of the thread and turns blue, and the question gets a green tick underneath it to show that a best answer has been selected :). - --Jen--, May 6, 2010