Home
Q&A
Help! Indirect and direct pronouns are killing me!

Help! Indirect and direct pronouns are killing me!

1
vote

Escribe esta frase otra vez, esta vez usando pronombres. ¡Lee los libros a nosotros!

Escribe esta frase otra vez, esta vez usando pronombres, y ahora escríbela negativamente. ¡Lee los libros a nosotros!

If you could help me with these that would be so amazing! Thank you!

6601 views
updated Mar 26, 2010
posted by Horseshowgirl924

4 Answers

1
vote

Actually, according to the rules provided in the lessons and in the Reference article here on this site your original sentence is incorrect.

According to the rules here, if the sentence contains an indirect object it should have an indirect object pronoun. Therefore, your original sentence should have been:

Léenos los libros a nosotros.

I have read other articles stating that if the i.o. follows the verb, this seemingly redundant, i.o.p. is not used.

Ignoring that, to replace the nouns with pronouns:

Affirmative sentence:

Léenoslos. (being an affirmative, informal command the pronouns must be appended to the verb. The 3rd, person, singular, present tense, indicative mood verb ending is used.)

Negative sentence:

No nos los leas. (being a negative, informal command the pronouns must precede the verb and the 2nd person, singular, present tense, subjunctive mood verb ending is used).

updated Mar 26, 2010
edited by 0074b507
posted by 0074b507
0
votes

Lee los libros a nosotros.

Read what? los libros. direct object To whom? a nosotros. indirect object.

Remember the acronym RID to determine the order of pronouns.

                               R = reflexive
                               I  = indirect object
                               D = direct object

In this case, the order would be nos los (ID)

Nos los lee.

To make it negative, place "no" before the pronoun. No nos los lee.

When both the direct and indirect pronouns begin with the letter "l", change the le or les to se.

Buena suerte

updated Mar 26, 2010
posted by Delores--Lindsey
In this context Nos los lee is incorrect as lee (tú) is a command and the pronouns must be attached to the verb. - 0074b507, Mar 26, 2010
commands aren't like gerunds or infinitives where the placement is optional - 0074b507, Mar 26, 2010
I read the sentence as being in the indicative. 3rd sing. - Delores--Lindsey, Mar 26, 2010
0
votes

"Leenoslos" it is always me , te , le ,nos , os, les + lo , la ,los , las ... But if you say Give him this.. or Give them this Be careful it is NOT "dalelo or daleslo".. No... It is "Daselo and daselo" ... to avoid le-lo , le-la , le-los and le las they use it like that but to make the meaning clear you need to say "Daselo a John." or "Daselo a ellos"....

updated Mar 26, 2010
posted by culé
0
votes

I feel your pain! These are very confusing and hard to learn. All I can do is give you a link to the reference section on this subject and tell you that "people always come before things," which means that if you use two object pronouns place the person before the thing. For example, "nos" goes before "los" in your sentence.

I wish I could help more. Let's wait for others to come along.

updated Mar 26, 2010
posted by --Mariana--