Home
Q&A
Is Borges' "La muerte y la brújula" too difficult for third year high school students?

Is Borges' "La muerte y la brújula" too difficult for third year high school students?

1
vote

I am interested in other opinions about the level of difficulty of "La muerte y la brújula" for high school students.

4359 views
updated Mar 25, 2010
posted by Delores--Lindsey

4 Answers

1
vote

no im a seinor i think kids need a challenge

updated Mar 25, 2010
posted by Audrey
Audrey, please use proper capitalization and punctuation in your posts. Thanks! - --Mariana--, Mar 24, 2010
Thanks for your answer. Good to hear that students want to be challenged. - Delores--Lindsey, Mar 25, 2010
2
votes

It's difficult to say, Delores, because a third year class in one school may be at a completely different level than a third year class at another school.

I don't know if you are asking because you are teaching or if you know a third year student who is having difficulties comprehending the material. It's not uncommon for a teacher to do a lot of "front loading" when presenting a challenging story to students, so what may appear to an outsider to be too much of a stretch for students really isn't that bad. If you are the teacher, a fair amount of front loading would be mandatory at this level.

There are so many things left unsaid in your post that this question is impossible to answer with any degree of accuracy.

updated Mar 25, 2010
posted by mountaingirl123
Thank you for your input. I am a teacher, and my students are doing this with some "front loading." - Delores--Lindsey, Mar 25, 2010
0
votes

Audrey needs lots of challenges, judging by her answer.

updated Mar 24, 2010
posted by William-Bassett
I think she gave a helpful answer. She may not have known about our spelling and punctuation rules. - Goyo, Mar 24, 2010
0
votes

Win^

updated Mar 24, 2010
posted by cgleason